The usage of electric vehicle batteries to assist the main electric grid for the storage of energy provided by intermittent sources should become an essential tool to increase the penetration of green energies. However, this service induces additional usage on the cells and, therefore, could degrade them further. Since degradation is path-dependent, it is of paramount importance to test the impact of all the different grid applications on the batteries. In this work, we tested the additional usage induced by using electric vehicle batteries for frequency regulation at moderate rates during rest or charge and found no detrimental effect after around 2000 cycles on the cells.
The main takeaway from our study was that some frequency regulation V2G usage at moderate rates (from C/5 to C/3 as a maximum current) did not accelerate the cell degradation despite close to 15% additional usage. In addition, there was no noticeable difference between performing this ancillary service during rest or charge or at maximum current fluctuations up to C/3 during rest and C/4 during charge. These results are extremely positive for the possible application of V2G/G2V strategies. However, it must be noted that our results hold for these specific cells and the duty cycle tested. More research is necessary to generalize the results. We already verified the results on another batch of commercial cells based on graphite//Nickel Cobalt Aluminum oxide.
Due to the lack of differences in the degradation between duty cycles, the benefits of modulating the charge to eliminate the additional usage on the cells could not be verified. Experiments on other chemistries with more aggressive usage will be launched to test the hypothesis further.
As for the diagnosis for the degradation, a new approach of coupling IC and DV analysis yielded four indicators for automatic diagnosis. This methodology will allow faster diagnosis and bolsters the value of the FOI approach for BMS implementation. However, our study also showed that under some conditions, in our case the apparent kinetic limitations, some of the FOI may become ineffective with time. Therefore, proper validation using full fits and sensibility analysis to check for the range of efficacy of chosen FOI is still essential.
Finally, some cells showcased the 2nd stage of aging and we were not able to predict it from the voltage variations. This suggested that it was not induced by a widespread degradation of the electrodes but was more likely because of localized effects. The cells that did not perform any frequency regulation seemed to be the most affected, but those results need to be moderated by the fact that the differences were probably within what to expect between cells performing the same duty cycles.