Introduction Acetaminophen-induced liver injury is the most common cause of acute liver failure, where multiple ingestions or a delay in the presentation may lead to a poor prognosis. N-acetylcysteine (NAC) is the conventional antidote used to treat acute acetaminophen toxicity, and plasmapheresis can be used as an adjunct, though there are no systematic studies to prove its effectivity. Case Presentation An 18-year-old girl was admitted with reduced responsiveness for one day with a few episodes of diarrhea. On admission, she was febrile and had a GCS of 10/15, otherwise normal neurology. She had marked right hypochodrial tenderness, deep icterus, and a pulse of 120 beats per minute, with a blood pressure of 80/50 mmHg; fluid resuscitation with inotropic support was done. Initial investigations revealed severe metabolic acidosis, hemoglobin of 9.5 g/dL, white blood cell count 13,500/mm3, and platelet 119,000 per µL. The prothrombin time (PT) international normalized ratio (INR) was 4.7, and the activated partial thromboplastin time (APTT) was 38.6. The alanine aminotransferase (ALT) level was 8118 U/L, and aspartate aminotransferase (AST) was 3883 U/L with a total bilirubin of 107 µmol/L. The diagnosis of acute liver failure following acetaminophen intoxication was made and managed with intravenous NAC, pantoprazole cover, intravenous ceftriaxone, metronidazole, thiamine, and vitamin K. Fresh frozen plasma and platelets were given for severe coagulopathy. She was started with plasmapheresis at the intensive care unit (ICU), where she had a significant improvement, though she developed hospital-acquired pneumonia, which was successfully managed. Subsequently, her liver functions returned to the baseline, and she was discharged after a psychiatric assessment. Conclusion A high degree of suspicion needs to be adopted to diagnose acetaminophen-induced acute liver failure when a patient presents with hepatic encephalopathy, and plasmapheresis can be considered a life-saving measure adjunct to the NAC.