Antiferroelectric
(AFE) materials, in which alternating dipole
moments cancel out to a zero net macroscopic polarization, can be
used for high-density energy storage and memory applications. The
AFE phase can exist in bulk CuInP2Se6, CuBiP2S6, and a few other transition-metal thiophosphates
below 200 K. The required low temperature poses challenges for practical
applications. In this work, we report the coexistence of ferrielectric
(FE) states and a stable surface phase that does not show piezoelectric
response (“zero-response phase”) in bulk CuInP2S6 at room temperature. Using piezoresponse force microscopy
(PFM) tomographic imaging together with density functional theory,
we find that direct and alternating voltages can locally and stably
convert FE to zero-response phases and vice versa. While PFM loops
show pinched hystereses reminiscent of antiferroelectricity, PFM tomography
reveals that the zero-response areas form only on top of the FE phase
in which the polarization vector is pointing up. Theoretical calculations
suggest that the zero-response phase may correspond to AFE ordering
where stacked CuInP2S6 layers have alternating
polarization orientations thereby leading to a net-zero polarization.
Consistent with experimental findings, theory predicts that the FE
polarization pointing down is robust up to the top surface, whereas
FE polarization pointing up energetically favors the formation of
an AFE surface layer, whose thickness is likely to be sensitive to
local strains. AFE order is likely to be more robust against detrimental
size effects than polar order, therefore providing additional opportunities
to create multifunctional heterostructures with 2D electronic materials.