Local women’s coalitions: Critical actors and substantive representation in Spanish municipalities

Abstract

The relationship between descriptive representation and substantive representation is an issue that has been widely discussed by women's studies scholars. In general, it is assumed that there exists a positive relationship between the two, but the literature and empirical analysis show that substantive representation also depends on the action of other critical actors, such as gender agencies and the women's social movement. Comparative research has shown the existence of a common pattern in post-industrial democracies: the development of women-friendly policies depends on the existence of coalitions between these critical actors. However, the analysis usually focuses on the national or regional level, and there is very little analysis at the local level, despite this being a political arena in which these processes can be developed. The aim of this article is to analyse the effect of coalitions of critical actors on the responsiveness to the demands of women's groups in the case of Spanish municipalities using a representative survey. The objective, therefore, is to apply advances in the women's substantive representation literature to the local level in Spain. Main results show that responsiveness is higher in municipalities where women's coalitions exist.The relationship between women's representation in electoral bodies (women's descriptive representation, WDR) and the development of women-friendly policies (women's substantive representation, WSR) is a substantial topic in women's studies literature,

Analysing the accounting measurement of financial sustainability in local governments through political factors

“…Gender equality in local government is another factor that could influence financial sustainability. Previous studies (Jennings, 1983; Rodríguez-Garcia, 2015) found that men had a higher level of political engagement and were more active managers than women. In parallel, following McGregor’s (1960) theory that the management style of women leaders is different and motivated towards common interest, women have been found to show more empathy for social problems, and hence reduce financial sustainability (Fox and Schuhmann, 1999; Ryan et al , 2005).…”

European Integral Urban Policies from a Gender Perspective. Gender-Sensitive Measures, Transversality and Gender Approaches

“…Projects also include actions to foster gender roles changes to facilitate compatibility between public space incorporation and the traditional care role within the home. Although the difference between URBAN and URBANA initiatives is small, the gender approach seems to be expanded in the later, either because work/life balance is explicitly one of its objectives or because of equality policies trends in Spain, as well as the critical actors that drive them at the local level [64,71]. This outcome points to the role that integrated urban development interventions can play concerning gender inequalities in local welfare systems, not just because of their attention to the classic inequalities that women face, but particularly because of their contribution to the development of defamilisation processes.…”

“…[61,62]. Although gender mainstreaming is not common in local governments [63], they have increasingly incorporated equality agencies and plans, albeit with differences according to the role played by critical actors and women's coalitions that promote the inclusion of gender issues in the municipal agenda [64].…”

Women's management in local government: The effects of substantive representation on welfare service efficiency

“…Among the different levels of public administration, local governments offer more opportunities to implement and evaluate the impact of the “balanced presence of women and men” in the public sector. The large number of politicians in Spanish local governments (67,515 representatives chosen in the 2015 municipal elections), their proximity to citizens and the provision of services related to women's preferences (Rodríguez‐García, 2015) make local governments the ideal context to assess the substantive representation of women in public services. One of the services where this impact can best be measured is welfare services, and more specifically, the protection of vulnerable groups in society (children, the elderly, the disabled, immigrants, etc.…”