6Many species use dormant stages for habitat selection by tying recovery from the stage 7 to informative external cues. Other species have an undiscerning strategy in which they 8 recover randomly despite having advanced sensory systems. We investigated the 9 nematode Caenorhabditis elegans dormant (dauer) stage to determine whether 10 elements of its habitat structure and life history have barred the species from evolving 11 a discerning recovery strategy. C. elegans colonization success is profoundly influenced 12 by the bacteria found in its habitat patches. We exposed dauers of three genotypes to a 13 range of bacteria acquired from the worms' natural habitat. We found that C. elegans 14 dauers recover in all conditions but increase recovery on certain bacteria depending on 15 the worm's genotype, suggesting a combination of undiscerning and discerning 16 strategies. Additionally, the worms' responses did not match the bacteria's objective 17 quality, suggesting that their decision is based on other characteristics. 18 19 20Many organisms use developmentally-arrested dormant stages to endure harsh environ-21 ments and/or disperse to better ones (Baskin and Baskin, 1998). Dormant stages must 22 recover to resume growth but this transition is often irreversible and exposes the individ-23 ual to new dangers (Raimondi, 1988). Therefore, individuals that assess local conditions 24 and tie this information to their recovery can increase their fitness (Keough and Downes, 25 1982). Unsurprisingly, this has led to the evolution of a diversity of discerning strategies 26 (Baskin and Baskin, 1998; Johnson et al., 1997). The cues that induce dormant stage re-27 covery are tailored to the organism's abiotic and biotic needs; the strategies can be as 28 simple as measuring temperature (Finch-Savage and Leubner-Metzger, 2006) or detect-29 ing conspecifics (Burke, 1986) and as complicated as parsing out signals from whole com-30 munities. Coral larvae, for example, can differentiate between algal species growing in a 31 prospective settlement site (Harrington et al., 2004). While many species develop these 32 discerning strategies, other species seem to adopt an undiscerning strategy, recovering 33 under all conditions, even poor ones (Keough and Downes, 1982). If these species have 34variable habitat qualities that impact their fitness, why aren't discerning strategies being 35 selected for? 36 One possible explanation is that discerning strategies only arise if they help organisms 37 avoid bad habitats and find good ones. A dormant organism may ignore salient informa-38 1 of 24 Manuscript submitted to eLife tion about its environment if it has no capacity to act on it (Raimondi, 1988). Behavioral 39 constraints, life history traits, and habitat structure may prevent the development of dis-40 cerning strategies, even when they would seem useful at first glance. In this project, we 41 investigated how the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans recovers from its dormant stage-42 the dauer (Fig. 1)-given that the species seems ...