“…Unfortunately, the disadvantages such as the high cost and low abundance greatly restrict the large-scale application of Pt in DSCs [6][7][8][9] . Thus, several Pt-free alternative materials have been explored as CEs in DSCs, such as carbon materials 8,10 , conductive organic polymers 6,11 and inorganic semiconductor materials including metal sulfides 12,13 , metal nitrides 14,15 , metal carbides 16,17 , metal oxides 18 and copper zinc tin sulfide 19 and so on. Recently, Wu et al 20 synthesized three classes (carbides, nitrides and oxides) of nanoscaled earlytransition metal catalysts and applied them in DSC systems as CE catalysts to replace the expensive Pt.…”