The present contribution provides a taxonomic reassessment of the Lower Cretaceous ammonite species Ammonites crassicostatus d'Orbigny (type species of Colombiceras Spath) and Ammonites gargasensis d'Orbigny (type species of Gargasiceras Casey) from the Aptian-type area (Apt, Vaucluse, southeastern France). Those nominal species represent two ornamental poles of a single population, here referred to C. crassicostatum. The genus Gargasiceras is, therefore, synonymised with Colombiceras. Implications on the taxonomy at the specific, generic, and supra-generic levels are discussed.