The free-living amebae Naegleria, Acanthamoeba, and Balamuthia cause rare but life-threatening infections. All three parasites can cause meningoencephalitis. Acanthamoeba can also cause chronic keratitis and both Balamuthia and Acanthamoeba can cause skin and systemic infections. There are minimal drug development pipelines for these pathogens despite a lack of available treatment regimens and high fatality rates. To identify anti-amebic drugs, we screened 159 compounds from a high-value repurposed library against trophozoites of the three amebae. Our efforts identified 38 compounds with activity against at least one ameba. Multiple drugs that bind the ATP-binding pocket of mTOR and PI3K are active, highlighting these compounds as important inhibitors of these parasites. Importantly, 24 active compounds have progressed at least to phase II clinical studies and overall 15 compounds were active against all three amebae. Based on central nervous system (CNS) penetration or exceptional potency against one amebic species, we identified sixteen priority compounds for the treatment of meningoencephalitis caused by these pathogens. The top five compounds are (i) plicamycin, active against all three free-living amebae and previously U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved, (ii) TG02, active against all three amebae, (iii and iv) FDA-approved panobinostat and FDA orphan drug lestaurtinib, both highly potent against Naegleria, and (v) GDC-0084, a CNS penetrant mTOR inhibitor, active against at least two of the three amebae. These results set the stage for further investigation of these clinically advanced compounds for treatment of infections caused by the free-living amebae, including treatment of the highly fatal meningoencephalitis.