Although a broad range of viruses cause myocarditis, the mechanisms that underlie viral myocarditis are poorly understood. Here, we report that the M2 gene is a determinant of reovirus myocarditis. The reovirus M2 gene encodes outer capsid protein µ1, which influences both cell entry and cell death. We infected newborn mice with reovirus strain type 1 Lang (T1L) or a reassortant reovirus in which the M2 gene from strain type 3 Dearing (T3D) was substituted into the T1L background (T1L/T3DM2). T1L was non-lethal in wild-type mice, whereas ~ 90% of mice succumbed to T1L/T3DM2. T1L/T3DM2 produced higher viral loads than T1L at the site of inoculation. In secondary organs, T1L/T3DM2 was detected with more rapid kinetics and reached higher peak titers than T1L. We found that hearts from T1L/T3DM2-infected mice were grossly abnormal, with large lesions corresponding to substantial cardiac injury with inflammatory infiltrates. Lesions in T1L/T3DM2-infected mice contained aggregates of necrotic cardiomyocytes with pyknotic debris, and prominent lymphocyte and histiocyte infiltration. In contrast, T1L induced the formation of smaller lesions in a subset of animals, consistent with T1L being mildly myocarditic. Finally, more activated caspase-3-positive cells were observed in hearts from animals infected with T1L/T3DM2 compared to T1L. Together, our findings indicate that substitution of the T3D M2 allele into an otherwise T1L genetic background is sufficient to change a non-lethal infection into a lethal infection. Our results further indicate that T3D M2 enhances T1L replication and dissemination in vivo, which potentiates the capacity of reovirus to cause myocarditis.