Machine learning of neuroimaging for assisted diagnosis of cognitive impairment and dementia: A systematic review

Abstract

Introduction Advanced machine learning methods might help to identify dementia risk from neuroimaging, but their accuracy to date is unclear. Methods We systematically reviewed the literature, 2006 to late 2016, for machine learning studies differentiating healthy aging from dementia of various types, assessing study quality, and comparing accuracy at different disease boundaries. Results Of 111 relevant studies, most assessed Alzheimer's disease versus healthy controls, using AD Neuroimaging Initiative data, support vector machines, and only T1-weighted sequences. Accuracy was highest for differentiating Alzheimer's disease from healthy controls and poor for differentiating healthy controls versus mild cognitive impairment versus Alzheimer's disease or mild cognitive impairment converters versus nonconverters. Accuracy increased using combined data types, but not by data source, sample size, or machine learning method. Discussion Machine learning does not differentiate clinically relevant disease categories yet. More diverse data sets, combinations of different types of data, and close clinical integration of machine learning would help to advance the field.

Statistical methods for dementia risk prediction and recommendations for future work: A systematic review

“…This might make them better suited to detect associations between variables than logistic or Cox regression [11]. However, as discussed by Pellegrini et al [8], in a published systematic literature and meta-analyses of machine learning techniques in neuroimaging for cognitive impairment and dementia, studies using machine learning algorithms also show limitations. Generalizability of results generated from the application of these techniques and their transfer to clinical use are likely to be constrained because of their over-reliance on one data source, the fact that they commonly use data from populations with greater proportions of cases (i.e., individuals with the diseases) and lower proportions of control subjects, they are usually derived using only one machine learning method and the application of varying validation methods [7,8].…”

Application of Big Data and Artificial Intelligence technologies to dementia prevention research: an opportunity for low-and-middle-income countries

“…Similar trends have also been observed in the analytics space where AI including sophisticated Machine Learning (ML) algorithms and frameworks such as deep learning continue to be developed and improved. A systematic review by Pellegrini et al [19] found over 110 publications on various initiatives where ML approaches have been employed to develop prediction models for cognitive impairment and AD using neuroimaging data. These research efforts are being extended to other data sources and domains such as linguistic analysis of text messages; speech analysis [20,21]; and also through the human eyes using retinal imaging [22] with promising results.…”

Deep MRI Segmentation: A Convolutional Method Applied to Alzheimer Disease Detection

“…Comparative evaluations were presented in [35], the authors presented a literature review of machine learning techniques used for AD detection. Their work illustrates the quality assessment of the previous studies and a comparison of the details.…”