Dear Sir,Martinez et al. [4], in their paper on magnesium excre tion in idiopathic hypercalciuria (HC), reported a paral lelism between calcium and magnesium excretion under the conditions studied, including calcium load (CL). However, it is unclear whether the correlation was ob tained independently in each group of HC or only when the 3 populations were studied together. Furthermore, only the regression coefficients were given, not allowing for a comparison of the effect of CL on the magnesiumcalcium relationship. Colussi et al. [1] found that after a CL, the increases in magnesium and calcium excretion were correlated in hyperabsorptive, but not in renal hy percalciuria. We wish to report briefly on our own results.26 hyperabsorptive (HA) and 22 renal (HR) hypercalciuric stone formers and II age-matched controls were studied. All were males to obviate hormonal influences, and they had normal GFR. Urine was collected on 2-hour periods, 2 periods before and 2 periods after a 635-mg oral calcium load. On the basis of the previously pub lished correlation in fasting controls [3], HC were further divided in group I(n = 27; 17 HA and 10 HR) where fasting M g/Cr was normal, and group II (n = 21; 9 HA and 12 HR) where fasting M g/C r was too low for the value of C a/C r (relative hypomagnesuria [4]).In group I, the correlation between M g/Cr and C a/C r (fasting and after CL) is depicted in figure 1. The correla tion was similar in HA (y = 0.064+ 0.409 x ; r = 0.82 left) and in HR (y = 0.035 + 0.411 x ; r = 0.67, right), and not different from that in controls (y = 0.093 +0.365 x ; r= 0.84). We agree with the comments by Martinez et al. [4] that changes in calcium and magnesium excretion after CL depend on parallel changes in the reabsorption of the 2 ions. However, the calcium concentration in the extra cellular fluid is probably more important than the intra tubular calcium, since calcium is known to modulate calcium and magnesium absorption by action on the contraluminal membrane [6,7] in the ascending limb, even in the absence of PTH. Furthermore, changes inCorrelation between urinary M g/Cr and C a/C r ratios, a Hy perabsorptive hypercalciuria (y = 0.064 +0.409 x ; r = 0.82). b Renal hypercalciuria (y = 0.035 + 0.411 x ; r = 0.67).