“…Tomographic imaging techniques, such as positron emission particle tracking (Parker et al, 1993) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) (Boyce et al, 2016;Candela et al, 2007;Huan et al, 2004;Lasič et al, 2006;Pavlin et al, 2007;Savelsberg et al, 2002) often suffer from temporal resolution too low to resolve rapid bubble dynamics; however, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) (Fabich et al, 2016;Müller et al, 2007c) and X-Ray (Fischer et al, 2008;Mudde, 2010) techniques have been used to measure instantaneous particle concentration fields within 3D fluidized beds. Recently, rapid MRI techniques have been developed (Penn et al, 2017) which enable imaging of bubble dynamics and the velocity field of particles surrounding bubbles in fluidized beds (Boyce et al, 2018;. Even with these techniques, the chaotic nature of the dynamics of many bubbles in freely bubbling beds make it difficult to characterize bubble interaction in a detailed and repeatable manner.…”