“…By scrutinizing the published data on Ge:Mn, one can observe three features in the reported AHE. First, most of the AHE curves shown were recorded at temperatures above 10 K. Indeed, Riss et al [50] reveal only ordinary Hall effect below 10 K. Second, no hysteresis in AHE curves has been observed, despite the observation of a clear hysteresis in magnetization, which is much different from the case of III-Mn-V and ZnMnTe [45,46,47]. Third, the Hall curve changes its sign of slope at lower temperatures, usually between 10 K and 50 K. Obviously, the correlation between magnetization, MR, and AHE, which is a hallmark of III-Mn-V and ZnMnTe FMS [45,46,47], has not been proven for Ge:Mn so far.…”