Magunkaquog Materiality, Federal Recognition, and the Search for a Deeper History

Abstract

This article explores the manner in which archaeology can address some of the issues that confront contemporary Native American groups trying to gain federal recognition. Often frustrating and at times capricious, the federal recognition process privileges documentary evidence over other forms of information in determining the political and cultural continuity demanded of groups seeking recognition. Demonstrating cultural continuity is hindered by the antiquated, assimilationist views that underpin the recognition process which equate the adoption of European cultural practices with the loss of Indian identity. This issue of authenticity is linked to even broader questions concerning materiality and the construction of identity. Drawing on archaeological and documentary investigations of the Christian Indian community of Magunkaquog, this paper explores the ambiguities of an archival record that can be challenged by material evidence. Archaeological evidence of cultural persistence discussed in the paper supports the political arguments of contemporary Native American groups that their ancestors maintained their political and cultural identity in the face of European colonization.

Re-emerging Frontiers: Postcolonial Theory and Historical Archaeology of the Borderlands

“…The pattern of spatial arrangements of these towns might have been relatively uniform. Daniel Gookin's description of another Praying Town established in Magunkaquog (within the boundaries of Natick and operating under its supervision) and the recent excavations on the site provide a very similar picture to that of early Natick (Herbster 2005;Mrozowski et al 2005Mrozowski et al , 2009). These settlements were a clear example of how frontiers and neighborhoods create opportunity for social and economic leverage, how they promote the creation of new roles and identities and how these diverse projects and negotiations make use of material objects.…”

The Study of Sustained Colonialism: An Example From the Kashaya Pomo Homeland in Northern California

“…This creates the impression that native peoples either disappeared or assimilated with the rise of the modern, pluralistic US nation. With the recent push to examine the full spectrum of colonialism, which includes nineteenth- and twentieth-century historical and contemporary contexts, a growing number of studies put indigenous people back on the central stage with settler colonists (e.g., Cipolla 2013; Mrozowski et al 2009; Silliman 2009, 2012).…”

Expanding mission archaeology: A landscape approach to indigenous autonomy in colonial California

“…When applied to the archaeology of colonialism, an examination of autonomy de-centers static, trait-based approaches to native cultures and the concomitant scholarly focus on externally-imposed change. By countering the myth of the vanishing Indian, such studies also offer opportunities for collaboration between archaeologists and indigenous communities (Cipolla, 2013;Mrozowski et al, 2009).…”