Early in mitosis, the mammalian Golgi apparatus disassembles, and fluorescence microscopy reveals Golgi clusters and an extensive, nonresolvable haze that either represents scattered vesicles or a merged endoplasmic reticulum (ER)-Golgi compartment. To help decide between these alternatives, we have carried out a combined microscopic and pharmacological analysis, by using a BS-C-1 cell line stably coexpressing ER and Golgi markers. Video fluorescence microscopy showed that these two organelles were morphologically distinguishable at all stages of mitosis, and photobleaching experiments showed that diffusion of the Golgi marker was unaffected by the presence of the ER. Fragmentation of the ER by using filipin III completely blocked diffusion of the ER marker but had no effect on the Golgi marker, unless it was first relocated to the ER by using brefeldin A. The Golgi haze was also studied using BODIPY ceramide. Its diffusion was slower in mitotic Golgi than in mitotic ER, but similar to that of a Golgi enzyme marker in the mitotic Golgi haze or in Golgi vesicles generated by ilimaquinone. Together, these results support the idea that the Golgi and the ER remain separate during mitosis and strongly suggest that Golgi markers move by vesicle diffusion, as opposed to lateral diffusion in continuous membranes.
INTRODUCTIONThe status of the Golgi apparatus as an organelle has been the subject of a long-running debate that focused initially on the route taken by transiting cargo (cisternal maturation or vesicle-mediated transport; Glick and Malhotra, 1998;Pelham and Rothman, 2000) and, more recently, on the mechanisms of duplication and partitioning that underlie its biogenesis (Marsh and Howell, 2002;Munro, 2002). If the Golgi apparatus is responsible for its biogenesis, then it can be viewed as an autonomous organelle (Pelletier et al., 2002). If, on the other hand, it depends on the endoplasmic reticulum, then it can be viewed as a dependent organelle, which exists only as a consequence of ER functioning (Zaal et al., 1999;Bevis et al., 2002;Munro, 2002).Golgi partitioning during mitosis in animal cells has been particularly controversial, with models ranging from partitioning by Golgi elements themselves (Lucocq et al., 1989;Misteli and Warren, 1995;Jesch and Linstedt, 1998;Shima et al., 1998;Jesch et al., 2001;Jokitalo et al., 2001) to the partial or even complete merger of the Golgi with the ER, which then mediates the partitioning process (Thyberg and Moskalewski, 1992;Zaal et al., 1999;Kano et al., 2000;Terasaki, 2000). Although most biochemical experiments have yielded consistent results, suggesting a separation of the ER and Golgi during mitosis (Jesch and Linstedt, 1998;Farmaki et al., 1999;Jesch et al., 2001), microscopic experiments have often yielded contradictory results (Thyberg and Moskalewski, 1992;Shima et al., 1998;Zaal et al., 1999;Jokitalo et al., 2001).A particular issue has been the Golgi haze observed by fluorescence microscopy of mitotic cells. Breakdown and fragmentation of the Golgi ribbon a...