Maintenance of species integrity in the context of a recent radiation: the case ofJamesbrittenia(Scrophulariaceae: Limoselleae) in southern Africa

Abstract

Incomplete post‐zygotic isolation poses challenges for the maintenance of species integrity in recently radiated lineages. An example is Jamesbrittenia, a southern African‐centred genus, the species of which cross readily to produce viable offspring. We develop a dated phylogenetic hypothesis for Jamesbrittenia and used this to assess the evidence for recent radiation and to evaluate the roles of geography, relatedness and floral divergence in determining the incidence of wild hybridization. Phylogenetic inference is based on nuclear (GScp) and plastid (rps16, psb–trnH) loci, but uses morphological evidence to resolve instances of supported incongruence. Our data reveal four ecologically and biogeographically differentiated lineages in Jamesbrittenia. One of these, a widespread and predominantly shrubby lineage, reflects accelerated diversification, potentially triggered by environmental change, starting in the late Miocene epoch. In the widespread clade, strong range exclusivity indicates an important role for geography in maintaining species identity. Among species with overlapping ranges, however, differentiation in floral form is a powerful predictor of wild hybridization. The apparent importance of geography in maintaining species integrity in recently diverged lineages, like the widespread clade of Jamesbrittenia, needs to be considered when species are translocated, whether such translocation is horticulturally motivated or forms part of an ‘assisted migration’ exercise.

Geography is essential for reproductive isolation between florally diversified morning glory species from Amazon canga savannahs

“…The establishment of a complete reproductive isolation between lineages of fruit fly requires 4 My 98 . Time-to-speciation among plants and animals is estimated at 2 My 99 ; 1 My in recent species radiation of African cichlid fish and Andean Lupinus 100 but full reproductive isolation requires more than 10–14 My in interfertile tulip trees 101 , 16 My in largely interfertile species in the genus Jamesbrittenia 102 and 60 My in ferns 103 . To understand whether divergence time insufficiency is one critical reason for weak postzygotic isolation and to reconfirm the taxonomic assertion of the sister species status 60 , it will be essential to estimate the age of I. cavalcantei and I. marabaensis diversification by the detailed phylogenetic reconstruction 100 of the Ipomoea genus clade Murucoides 62 .…”