We show that the topologically trivial zero bias peak (ZBP) emerging in semiconductor Majorana wires due to soft confinement exhibits correlated splitting oscillations as a function of the applied Zeeman field, similar to the correlated splitting of the Majorana ZBP. Also, we find that the presence of a strong impurity can effectively cut the wire in two and destroy the correlated splitting in both the trivial and the Majorana regimes. We identify a strong nonlocal effect that operates only in the topologically trivial regime and demonstrate that the dependence of the ZBP on the confining gate potential at the opposite end in Majorana wires with two normal metal endcontacts represents a powerful tool for discriminating between topologically trivial and nontrivial ZBPs.First predicted in the context of high energy physics, Majorana fermions (MF) [1] have come under renewed focus in low-temperature condensed matter physics [1-3] as zeroenergy bound states endowed with non-Abelian statistics [4], hence, potential suitable candidates for fault-tolerant quantum computation [5,6]. Proposals for realizing MFs in lowtemperature systems are based on fractional quantum Hall systems [4,7], chiral p-wave superconductors/superfluids [7,8], heterostructures of topological insulators and superconductors [9], and cold fermion systems [10,11]. The recently proposed scheme based on spin-orbit coupled semiconductor thin films [12][13][14][15] and nanowires [15][16][17] with Zeeman splitting and proximity induced s-wave superconductivity involves only conventional ingredients. The semiconductor Majorana wire -the 1D version [15][16][17] of the semiconductorsuperconductor (SM-SC) heterostructure -represents a direct physical realization of the one-dimensional Kitaev model [5]. The observation of a sharp zero bias conductance peak (ZBP) in charge tunneling measurement has been proposed [15,[18][19][20][21][22] as a possible detection scheme for MFs localized near the ends of Majorana nanowires. The 1D SM-SC heterostructure and the associated ZBP measurements have recently attracted considerable experimental effort [23][24][25][26][27][28][29][30].Despite significant progress, the actual observation of MFs in SM nanowires is still under debate, as signatures similar to the Majorana-induced ZBPs are predicted to occur even in the topologically trivial phase in the presence of smooth confining potentials [31], or strong disorder [32]. On the other hand, due to the overlap of the wave functions localized near the opposite ends, the Majorana ZBP is characterized by splitting oscillations as a function of the Zeeman field or the chemical potential. The ZBPs measured at the opposite ends of a clean wire should be characterized by the same splitting oscillations (correlated splitting), since they involve the same wave function overlap. The direct observation of correlated splitting has been recently proposed [33] as a tool for identifying Majorana-induced ZBPs.In this Rapid Communication we show that topologically trivial ZBPs emerging in SM...