Making Sense of Low Back Pain and Pain-Related Fear

Abstract

Synopsis Pain-related fear is implicated in the transition from acute to chronic low back pain and the persistence of disabling low back pain, making it a key target for physical therapy intervention. The current understanding of pain-related fear is that it is a psychopathological problem, whereby people who catastrophize about the meaning of pain become trapped in a vicious cycle of avoidance behavior, pain, and disability, as recognized in the fear-avoidance model. However, there is evidence that pain-related fear can also be seen as a common-sense response to deal with low back pain, for example, when one is told that one's back is vulnerable, degenerating, or damaged. In this instance, avoidance is a common-sense response to protect a "damaged" back. While the fear-avoidance model proposes that when someone first develops low back pain, the confrontation of normal activity in the absence of catastrophizing leads to recovery, the pathway to recovery for individuals trapped in the fear-avoidance cycle is less clear. Understanding pain-related fear from a common-sense perspective enables physical therapists to offer individuals with low back pain and high fear a pathway to recovery by altering how they make sense of their pain. Drawing on a body of published work exploring the lived experience of pain-related fear in people with low back pain, this clinical commentary illustrates how Leventhal's common-sense model may assist physical therapists to understand the broader sense-making processes involved in the fear-avoidance cycle, and how they can be altered to facilitate fear reduction by applying strategies established in the behavioral medicine literature. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 2017;47(9):628-636. Epub 13 Jul 2017. doi:10.2519/jospt.2017.7434.

Is it time to reframe how we care for people with non-traumatic musculoskeletal pain?

“…First, structural changes observed on imaging that are highly prevalent in pain free populations, such as rotator cuff tears, intervertebral disc degeneration, labral tears and cartilage changes, are ascribed to individuals as a diagnosis for their condition. In this context, this information may result in the individual believing that their body is damaged, fragile and in need of protection, resulting in a cascade of movement and activity avoidance behaviours and seeking interventions to correct the structural deficits 1. This trend has led to exponential increases in elective surgery rates and associated costs, while the efficacy of repairing (eg, rotator cuff and medical meniscal tears), reshaping (eg, subacromial decompression) or replacing (eg, lumbar intervertebral discs) the structures considered to be at fault has been substantially challenged 2–10…”

Use of cognitive behavioural therapy with usual physical therapy intervention for individuals who are unemployed secondary to chronic low back pain: A case series

“…Education on the neurophysiology of pain as described in Jones, Valenzuela, Booth, Taylor and Barry (), emphasizing patients’ feelings of control over the pain process, was provided. Fear‐avoidance behaviours were discouraged, utilizing the fear‐avoidance model as described by Bunzi et al ().…”

“…Trunk motor control, including the identification of aberrant movements, was noted during seated and standing lumbar mobility assessment. Aberrant movement is defined as altered lumbopelvic rhythm, deviation from the sagittal plane, instability catch or judder and/or painful arch of motion, and its presence could be a result of fear-avoidance movement(Bunzli, Smith, Schutze, Lin, & O'Sullivan, 2017;Walston & Yake, 2016).…”

Risk Factors for the Elevation of Psychosocial Barriers in the Recovery of Lumbar Pathology

“…Individuals with both acute and persistent low back pain have already been shown to have decreased quality of sleep [68][69][70]. In addition, sleep disturbances are labeled as one of many pain sensitizing factors in individuals with low back pain [71].…”