Comment. Malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumors are rare tumors that originate from peripheral or cranial nerves or result from malignant transformation of a benign schwannoma or neurofibroma. 2-4 They may sometimes be confused with amelanotic melanomas. In our case, the lack of KIT mutations and the absence of melanosomes in any of the cells were consistent with a diagnosis of MPNST rather than amelanotic melanoma. 4 Although MPNSTs can invade the paranasal sinuses, origin within the sinuses is extremely rare. 2 These tumors almost never affect the cranial nerves, but when they do, the nerve most commonly affected is the facial nerve. 3 We are unaware of any cases in which an OMNP was the manifesting sign. This case is even more unusual in that neither the size nor the reactivity of the pupil was affected.What was the cause of third nerve palsy in our case? One possibility is that it was related not to the tumor but to the patient's underlying vascular disease. This would be consistent with the painless onset of the palsy and its complete resolution after about 7 months, although this is somewhat longer than one would expect in such a setting. Although lesions of the sphenoid sinus do not commonly produce third nerve palsies, a few such examples have been reported. 5,6 Thus, the mass could have affected the oculomotor nerve in the anterior cavernous sinus by compression, by producing an inflammatory reaction, or by causing focal ischemia. Any of these mechanisms could account for the rapid resolution of the palsy following resection of the lesion. In any event, this case provides support for the recommendation that a patient with an isolated, complete, pupil-sparing OMNP be evaluated with neuroimaging when there is no evidence of improvement after several months. A u t h o r A f f i l i a t i o n s : D e p a r t m e n t o f N e u r oophthalmology, Wilmer Eye Institute (Drs Fard and Miller