Due to the important important role that the application of mathematical programming models have in determining optimal cropping patterns, this research presents a sustainable cropping pattern that considers selected economic, environmental, and social goals together. Using a random sampling method, a sample size of 168 farmers was selected in the Sari County, Iran. Our results showed that economic, self-sufficiency, environmental, and social goals have a distinctly different impact on cropping pattern performance. Compared to the current cropping pattern, the gross margins for economic and social goals increased by nearly 11% and 2%, respectively, and the gross margins for self-sufficiency and environmental goals decreased by nearly 2% and 36%. Interestingly, it has been found that the performance of the current cropping pattern has an average positive impact of 6% if economic, self-sufficiency, environmental, and social (employment) goals are realized simultaneously.