Managing Competition Risk: A Critical Realist Philosophical Exploration

Abstract

As firms act to meet competitive challenges, they separately vary their exposure to objectively real risks, and their subjective risk perceptions. Hence the ‘fit’ between each firm's subjective risk map and its objective ‘riskscape’ is in constant flux. Realist thought, which emphasizes the separateness of mind from external reality, and sets itself the slow and painstaking task of improving the fit between the two, is therefore universally relevant for risk management. This simple ‘risk realism’ has value for academics wishing to analyse risk management practice and can provide useful working assumptions and procedural guidelines for practitioners. Mindful of both uses, this paper utilizes the philosophical thesis of critical realism to develop ontological and epistemological standpoints that relate specifically to what we call ‘competition risk’. Working from these standpoints we develop parallels between business and military engagements with competition risk. We explore what we treat as ontologically indistinct competition risk issues present across both contexts and conclude that firms can learn much from how the military deals with both ‘regular’ and ‘irregular’ forms of competition risk.

Effect of Project Risk Management on Performance of Social Development Projects in Rwanda: A Case of VUP Financial Services Project in Gakenke District

“…This indicates a moderate level of explanation and indicate that the included predictors collectively contribute to understanding project performance. The findings from this study resonate with Ojiako et al (2021), who stress the importance of evaluating project performance not only in terms of meeting time, cost, and quality objectives but also in terms of satisfying client needs in a sustainable and satisfactory manner. The positive correlations observed between various aspects of risk management (risk control, identification, analysis, and response) and project performance align with their assertion that continuous improvement and lessons learned from previous projects contribute to better project outcomes.…”

Forecasting unknown-unknowns by boosting the risk radar within the risk intelligent organisation

“…We further contend that it is important to understand how organisations which normally compete 'within the rules' are likely to effectively recognise, monitor and manage threat actions that are purposeful, targeted and sometimes episodically repeating, yet hard to predict because the agencies are anonymous and prepared to violate laws and other norms. We recognise from learning-from-the-military literature (Ojiako et al, 2010(Ojiako et al, , 2012, that current risk management capabilities are underprepared for unconventional threats and competitive behaviours that subvert well recognised conventions. Also of interest within that context is Chen and Miller's (1994) suggestion that even reputable firms may engage in targeted threat actions when they deem the targeted firms major obstacles to their survival.…”

“…This will enable us to outline a consolidated risk intelligence process, and by that token offer an outline vision of the risk intelligent organisation. Maguire et al (2009) and Ojiako et al (2010Ojiako et al ( , 2012 contend that competency to exploit novel situations has often eluded organisations. Furthermore, studies dealing with how businesses can learn from the military (Darling et al, 2005;Ojiako et al, 2010;Roche and Blaine, 2015) suggest that organisations, especially those competing in dynamic environments against irregular social threats from competitors, regulators, advocacy organisations, criminals, cyber-hackers and the like, can learn much from military approaches to combating irregular military threat.…”

A futility, perversity and jeopardy critique of “risk appetite”

“…The "appetites" in question have been of particular interest to scholars such as Bebchuk and Spamann (2009), Crotty (2009) and Sharma (2012) who are interested in excessive corporate risk-taking in US financial services. According to Ojiako et al (2012) and some common strands within risk sociology help us to theorise what is at issue The notion of "edgework" articulated by Lyng (2005), reminds us that voluntary risktaking often seeks psychological payoffs from exploring cultural boundaries, particularly through risky transgression. Here we might certainly consider the predicament of the manager constrained by risk appetite, particularly where there is ambiguity related to the specification and/or opportunity to engage in some risky activity whose level of risk is ambiguous.…”