Managing Sustainable Hybrid Organisations: A Case Study in the Agricultural Sector

Abstract

Abstract:Research in the field of sustainability has been dominated by an instrumental logic in which social and environmental aspects are reduced to their ability to generate financial benefits. However, the increasing problems facing society are highlighting the need to change this logic. In this context, a growing body of literature is developing around what are known as hybrid organisations, entities characterised by their combination of a social and/or environmental mission with the pursuit of economic benefit. This research uses a descriptive case study approach in order to examine how a Spanish winery-Celler la Muntanya-has implemented a sustainable business model to create positive social and environmental change. The agricultural sector is receiving increasing attention in the sustainability field because of its impact on society and the territory. In addition, agricultural activity generates tensions between social/environmental dimensions-such as the preservation of ecosystems and biodiversity-and economic benefits. Our case study draws on the 'sustainability-driven hybrid business model' and its three basic elements: social and environmental change as organizational objective; mutually beneficial relationships with stakeholders; and progressive interaction with markets, competitors and industry institutions. Our findings contribute to the literature by helping to explain how agricultural organisations can implement their business model based on sustainability criteria.

Opening the organisational black box to grasp the difficulties of agroecological transition. An empirical analysis of tensions in agroecological production cooperatives

“…Nonetheless, many scholars postulate that these internal tensions should not be understood negatively as trade-offs and according to an 'either/or' model but as paradoxes that lead to productive transformations (Jay, 2013;Smith et al, 2017). As a result of their persistence over time and their interdependency nature ('both/and' model), paradoxical tensions actually expand the potential for individual creativity and organisational innovation (Diaz-Correa and López-Navarro, 2018;Dufays, 2019). Within hybrid organizations, analysing the construction of dynamic equilibriums (Smith and Lewis, 2011) helps to identify how actors translate conflicting imperatives into a set of tangible responses and practices (Pache and Santos, 2010), while preventing letting one logic, with its objectives and practices, from dominating another.…”

Exploring business models for sustainability: A bibliographic investigation of the literature and future research directions

“…As regards ‘Different types of BMfS’, a few studies enlarged the literature on entrepreneurship (Agrawal & Gugnani, 2014), hybrid companies (Alberti & Varon Garrido, 2017; Díaz‐Correa & López‐Navarro, 2018; Kolk & Lenfant, 2016), SMEs (Dubruc et al, 2017) and B corp (Stubbs, 2019). Another perspective is provided by Khmara and Kronenberg (2018), who investigated the BMfS based upon the degrowth paradigm.…”

Business models for environmental sustainability: Contemporary shortcomings and some perspectives

“…Among the typologies of BMs for ES, some papers addressed BMs in the case of specific sectors (e.g., Ford & Despeisse, 2016; Pal & Gander, 2018; Johannsdottir 2014; Yip & Bocken, 2018), like energy and renewable energy (Bryant, Straker, & Wrigley, 2018; Flodén & Williamsson, 2016; Hellström, Tsvetkova, Gustafsson, & Wikström, 2015; Rohrbeck, Konnertz, & Knab, 2013; Strupeit & Palm, 2016), including BM as a tool to explore photovoltaic systems or the case of BMs in the biofuel transport. Other authors explored sustainability and BMs in the context of the beer and wine sector (Díaz‐Correa & López‐Navarro, 2018; Wells, 2016). Some studies deal with BMs in mining (Bini, Bellucci, & Giunta, 2018) and bioplastic fashion industry (Iles & Martin, 2013).…”