The West African mangrove oyster, Crassostrea tulipa (Lamarck, 1819), has the potential to improve global shellfish food production and is being considered for commercial farming in many countries in West Africa. The current background information to support this venture is, however, inadequate especially with respect to identification of suitable materials for optimal collection of spat for large-scale production. We assessed the effectiveness of five locally available materials (coconut shell, oyster shell, nylon mesh, PVC, and ceramic tile) for harvesting C. tulipa spat from the Densu Delta, Narkwa Lagoon, Benya Lagoon and Whin Estuary, along the coast of Ghana from November 2017 to October 2018. Ceramic tile had the highest mean monthly spat settlement in the Narkwa Lagoon (3451 ± 206 spat m-2), Benya Lagoon (1769 ± 145 spat m-2) and Whin Estuary (373.1 ± 52.4 spat m-2). This settlement was not significantly different from settlement on PVC slats (P > 0.05). Coconut shell consistently had the least C. tulipa spatfall in all four coastal water bodies (P < 0.05). The under-horizontal surfaces of collectors, [mean (S.E.); 2523.7 ± 66.9 spat m-2] had significantly more C. tulipa spatfall than upper-horizontal surfaces [mean (S.E.); 775.2 ± 33.4 spat m-2] in the main experiment (P = 0.000). In a separate experiment, a change of orientation from “Face down”/0° to “Face up”/180° did not change the observed profuse under-horizontal settlement of C. tulipa spat on the collectors, suggesting that under-horizontal surfaces were more attractive to C. tulipa spat. Larger-sized C. tulipa spat on under-horizontal surfaces, mean (S.E.) 9.88 ± 0.5 mm, compared to upper-horizontal surfaces, mean (S.E.) 5.99 ± 0.5 mm, of the collectors suggest earlier settlement on the undersides. Ceramic tiles and PVC slats were the most effective materials for C. tulipa spat collection, hence, their use recommended for large-scale C. tulipa farming.