Mapping the flat glass value-chain: a material flow analysis and energy balance of UK production

Abstract

Glass is one of the UK’s eight energy-intensive industries. As such, it is under scrutiny to decouple growth in production from greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. Recycled glass, also known as cullet, requires less energy to melt than primary raw materials in new glass production. The use of cullet thus reduces the energy intensity per unit of output whilst also reducing demand for primary material resources. However, efficient systems for flat glass collection are yet to be established in the UK, resulting in a limited supply of cullet available for the flat glass market and missed environmental opportunities. This study identifies the existing supply-chain inefficiencies in the UK glass industry in three stages. Firstly, the mass flows of materials within the three main glass sectors: container glass, flat glass and glass wool, are mapped from natural resource through to primary application and subsequent end-of-life management based on a reference year of annual production figures. The map is presented in the form of a “Sankey” diagram which draws attention to several opportunities for increasing resource efficiency; namely in the stark contrast in glass collection rates between the flat and container glass industry. Using the data collected on the annual mass flows of materials in the UK flat glass sub-sector, the energy (MJ) and GHG emission (CO2-eq) saving potential of enhanced end-of-life collection methods are assessed, based on three alternative recovery scenarios. These scenarios consider the use of alternative distributions of recovered flat glass cullet in the three primary glass sub-sectors. The emission savings resulting from each recovery scenario are evaluated, based on the estimated tonnage yield of finished flat glass products. It is shown that together with improved manufacturing yield, the reutilization of end-of-life flat glass as cullet in new production could reduce the annual emissions of the UK flat glass value-chain by up to 18.6%. Finally we review the existing barriers to recycling different glass types based on acceptability criteria and available take-back infrastructure, and thus find that the advancement of improved recycling rates will rely on establishing the business opportunity and/or supporting policy for developing efficient systems for flat glass collection.

Alternative raw material research for decarbonization of UK glass manufacture

“…4,59,60 We can thus infer that the UK container glass sector consumed ∼0.4 Mt sodium carbonate per year. 4,59,60 If we consider only the potassium in biomass ash as a partial replacement for the sodium in sodium carbonate, theoretically, the biomass ash can save 56 000-98 000 tonnes of sodium carbonate in the UK container glass sector per year, which is up to 25% of its sodium carbonate consumption. In addition, based on these estimates, the partial replacement of sodium carbonate by biomass ash in glass batches could potentially save up to 64 000 tonnes of CO 2 emissions per year across the UK glass sector.…”

“…Combustion of virgin herbaceous biomass produces 5–9 wt.% ash 58 and the annual yield of this biomass ash is approximately 48.5–87.3 kilotons. It is estimated that in 2019 approximately 0.66 Mt sodium carbonate was consumed by the UK glass sector, based on typical glass‐making recipes 4,59,60 . We can thus infer that the UK container glass sector consumed ∼0.4 Mt sodium carbonate per year 4,59,60 .…”

“…It is estimated that in 2019 approximately 0.66 Mt sodium carbonate was consumed by the UK glass sector, based on typical glass‐making recipes 4,59,60 . We can thus infer that the UK container glass sector consumed ∼0.4 Mt sodium carbonate per year 4,59,60 . If we consider only the potassium in biomass ash as a partial replacement for the sodium in sodium carbonate, theoretically, the biomass ash can save 56 000–98 000 tonnes of sodium carbonate in the UK container glass sector per year, which is up to 25% of its sodium carbonate consumption.…”

Case Study on the Re-use Potential of Insulated Glass Units

“…Intuitively, the reuse of glass panes as substitute to freshly produced glass occurs to be the most promising strategy to minimize the environmental impact in the lifecycle of float glass products (Hartwell & Overend, 2019). However, in practice there are a series of challenges to be addressed before reuse can be considered or rejected as a viable option.…”