Marine Conservation Begins at Home: How a Local Community and Protection of a Small Bay Sent Waves of Change Around the UK and Beyond

Abstract

The Firth of Clyde, on the west coast of Scotland, was once one of the most productive fishing grounds in Europe. However, successive decades of poor management and overfishing led to a dramatic loss of biodiversity and the collapse of finfish fisheries. In response, concerned local residents on the Isle of Arran, which lies in the middle of the Clyde, formed the Community of Arran Seabed Trust (COAST) in 1995. After 13 years of campaigning, a small (2.67 km 2) area in Lamlash Bay became Scotland's first no-take zone (NTZ) in 2008, and only the second in the UK. Since protection, biodiversity has increased substantially, along with the size, age and density of commercially important species such as the king scallop, Pecten maximus, and the European lobster, Homarus gammarus. Arguably more important, however, is the influence the Lamlash Bay NTZ and COAST have had on UK marine protection in general. Most notably, detailed research has created a case study that clearly demonstrates the benefits of protection in an area where little such evidence is available. This case has been used repeatedly to support efforts for increased protection of UK waters to help rebuild marine ecosystems and enhance their resilience in an uncertain future. In Scotland specifically, lobbying by COAST led to the designation of a much larger marine protected area (MPA, >250 km 2) around the south of Arran, one of 30 new MPAs in the country. Evidence from Lamlash Bay has supported development of strong protection for these MPAs, seeing off lobbyist efforts to weaken management. Arran's conservation success has been recognized internationally and is inspiring greater involvement of local communities around the UK, and further afield, to take the destiny of their coastal waters into their own hands. Successful marine conservation begins at home.

Connecting to the oceans: supporting ocean literacy and public engagement

“…For example, in the case of a mussel fishery in the Dutch Wadden Sea, knowledge co-production between resource users, science and policy led to a shared knowledge-base and improved governance of the fishery, which helped to stabilise conflict and controversy associated with the fishery (van der Molen et al 2015 ). In Scotland, the Community of Arran Seabed Trust ( COAST ) initiative established a community-led ecosystem research programme that provided the impetus for further scientific monitoring, and eventually resulted in a collaborative community, science and policy effort to designate 30 marine protected areas in Scottish Waters (Stewart et al 2020 ). Training opportunities for scientists to engage with policy (e.g.…”

Ocean Optimism: Moving Beyond the Obituaries in Marine Conservation

“…Small MPAs remain the norm in many developing countries because of the impracticality of excluding large areas from fishing, and even in the main Hawaiian Islands, the median area of protection is only 1.2 km 2 (Friedlander et al 2019). Although by definition what they directly protect is small, their success can transform conservation more broadly by significantly stimulating other efforts and helping shape policies at various levels, as has occurred, for example, in the Philippines (Alcala & Russ 2006) and the United Kingdom (Stewart et al 2020). Small MPAs can also protect habitats of outsized importance, such as spawning sites (see above) and other critically important habitats (e.g., feeding and resting grounds for migrating shorebirds).…”

Marine biology on a violated planet: from science to conscience

“…Ideally, an overview of the problems (which still must be referred to accurately) should be followed by practicable solutions and by positive examples that illustrate ways of shifting our values and behaviour towards less destructive economic systems (e.g. Duarte et al 2020, Stewart et al 2020.…”