Maritime security and the Blue Economy: intersections and interdependencies in the Indian Ocean

Abstract

Maritime security is essential to supporting the Blue Economy. Many maritime security forums have been key supporters of the Blue Economy concept, particularly in the Indian Ocean region (IOR). This paper will explore the co-evolution and co-dependence of Blue Economy and maritime security agendas, with a particular focus on the IOR. It identifies two primary interactions between Blue Economy and maritime security interests. Firstly, maritime security is an enabler of the Blue Economy, for example, through safeguarding navigation routes, providing important oceanographic data to marine industries and protecting rights over valuable marine resources and activities within claimed zones of maritime jurisdiction. Secondly, an often overlooked role that maritime security plays in the Blue Economy is by being itself a source of economic development and growth. An expanded Blue Economy will create greater demand for maritime security capabilities, and this, in turn, will trigger increased investment and growth in these capabilities. The enhanced and increasingly diverse role that maritime security will continue to play in the Blue Economy can be seen across all sectors in the IOR.

Shades of blue: what do competing interpretations of the Blue Economy mean for oceans governance?

“…Maritime security can be seen as both an enabler of the Blue Economy -for example, by protecting trade routes and providing important oceanographic and use data to industry -and as itself a sector of the Blue Economy (Voyer et al, 2018). Maritime security is seen as crucial to creating the secure and stable environment for the development of a Blue Economy.…”

‘Blue boats’ and ‘reef robbers’: A new maritime security threat for the Asia Pacific?

“…Recognising food insecurity as a major risk to international peace, of which fisheries form a vital supply in many parts of the world (Cohen and Pinstrup‐Andersen, ; Pomeroy et al ., ), this particular threat also invites human security concerns affecting the vulnerability and resilience of coastal populations as well as the welfare of seafaring fish workers (Adger, ; Bueger, ; Macfarlane, ). Likewise, intentional and unlawful damage to the marine environment and climate change uncertainty are also key parts of the maritime security discussion, for their potential to destabilise social and economic interests of coastal states through, for instance, creating environmental refugees or derailing the pursuit of the ‘blue economy’, which requires secure and well‐managed marine environments as a precondition to ocean‐based sustainable development (Klein et al ., ; Duarte, ; Barnett, ; Voyer et al ., ).…”

Criminal Threats Undermining Indo-Pacific Maritime Security: Can International Law Build Resilience?

“…Given the pristine waters, peppering of uninhabited islands, marine life and reefs, tourism opportunity within the Indo-Pacific region is aplenty and in time, it is likely for the cruising tourism to return to regenerate. While compared to other regions such as the Mediterranean or the Caribbean, the Indo-Pacific is not a cruising hot-spot, however, given the explosion of the cruising tourism industry in recent years, there is potential for the Indo-Pacific to increase in desirability (Voyer et al, 2018). Again drawing on broken windows theory, given the high number of Indo-Pacific states where terrorism threats exist, there is potential for cruise vessels to be targeted and proactive, regionally aligned responses to maritime terrorism must not be ignored (Kelling & Wilson, 1982; Potgieter & Schofield, 2010).…”