Market Structure and Competition in the Indian Microfinance Sector

Abstract

Executive Summary The Indian microfinance sector has experienced fundamental changes in the structure of ownership and management of microfinance institutions (MFIs). The current study seeks to evaluate the competition level of the Indian microfinance sector during the period 2005–2017 and attempts to find the cause-and-effect relationship between concentration and competition. Furthermore, it analyzes the performance of leading MFIs to explore if there is evidence of exploitation of clients by these institutions. The study is the first of its kind with explicit focus on the market structure of the Indian microfinance market. The study uses unbalanced panel data sets generated from the microfinance information exchange (MIX) data source. The representative sample includes firm specific data of 127 MFIs of different legal statuses and sizes. The dynamic equation model is estimated applying the difference generalized methods of moments (GMM). The results of the empirical investigation find a rise in the concentration with a decrease in competition in the Indian microfinance market during recent years. Intense competition in the past and introduction of new regulations in the wake of sectoral crisis are responsible for this transition. High concentration gives large MFI market powers to exploit the customers. However, the study fails to find any evidence of any such exploitation from the conduct of the leading MFIs. The survey highlights the potential connection between the drop in the competitiveness of the sector and the first appearance of new regulations in light of the sectoral crisis. It is imperative that regulators keep a tight vigil on the operations of leading MFIs and take necessary actions to ensure a healthy competitive environment in the sector. Furthermore, existing rules should be modified to help small MFIs as they play a very crucial role in the fulfilment of the primary objective of the microfinance.

Estructura de mercado del sector bancario y su relación con el crecimiento económico: una revisión de literatura

“…Cabe mencionar que, en algunos casos, el estadístico H estimado es más elevado y cercano a 1, lo que significa que el sector bancario tiene un poder de mercado débil y se acercan a la competencia perfecta. Sin embargo, alto concentración otorga a las grandes empresas poderes de mercado, pueden explotarse para obtener más beneficios cobrando altas tasas de interés sobre los préstamos (Navin & Sinha, 2019).…”

Market Structure and Competition of Nepalese Commercial Banking Industry

“…Several research papers in the banking industry have shown the importance of competition in the area, stating its effects on market concentration and market power, social welfare, pricing, entry of foreign banks, stability, accessibility to financial services, effectiveness, and merger and acquisition (Claessens & Leavens, 2004;Bikker & Spierdijk, 2009;Divino & Silvia, 2017;Kandaswamy et al, 2018;Joaquim et al, 2019;Navin & Sinha, 2019;Yunita, 2019). The idea behind banking competition is that any business, including banking, can be dangerous due to market dominance (Leon, 2014).…”