The masking of a brief tonal signal by continuous and gated sinusoids was investigated. Masking patterns depicting the threshold of a signal of frequency f• as a function of masker frequency f• for the two masker presentations were compared. In the frequency region f• > f•, the briefly presented gated masker was always a more effective masker than the continuous steady-state background, even under conditions in which energy spread of the gated masker was minimized. For f• < f•, the gated-continuous threshold shift, sometimes called the "overshoot," reversed when a low-level background noise was added to the tonal masker in order to mask audible combination tones. The presence of combination tones in the steady-state masker condition precluded application of a simple energy detection model in the frequency region f• < f•. An attempt to simulate the results for f• > f• with an energy-detection scheme in conjunction with a detailed spectral analysis of the stimuli was also unsuccessful. Subject Classification: 65.58, 65.50, 65.75.