Matching the production of doctors with national needs

Abstract

Context Matching the supply of health workers to need is necessary if a health system is to be sustainable, affordable and fit for purpose. On the 30th anniversary of the 1988 Edinburgh Declaration of the World Federation for Medical Education, levels of compliance with the 10th recommendation, ‘Ensure admission policies that match the numbers of students trained with national needs for doctors’, warrant review. There are two domains to such a review, concerning, respectively, how well these health needs are known, and whether workforce supply is well matched. Methods This is a literature review‐based analysis of extant health system planning, which underpins current understanding of national health needs and of the consequent alignment of student selection processes. Results The core finding is that national need for doctors, and any other health workers, is not confidently known for any jurisdiction. Consequently, validation of student selection processes is impossible against this endpoint and data to validate these processes against the alternative endpoint of a positive impact on health outcomes do not exist. Data do exist to suggest some student selection processes result in desirable career and career location uptakes.

Taking a break: doctors opt out of training after foundation year 2

“…The relation between medical school admissions policies and medical workforce planning is not simple or linear 9. Shifting the focus of admissions, however, from a stifling emphasis on high academic achievement10 to a model better aligned with social accountability would be a good first step towards a better match between the two.…”

Will Australia have a fit‐for‐purpose medical workforce in 2025?

“…Gorman contended that New Zealand needs a “core workforce that can be employed flexibly and redeployed quickly” with a “scope of practice that is as general as possible, while such practitioners work at the top end of their licence” 6 . Gorman also noted the lack of agreed national workforce goals in any jurisdiction 7 and recommended workforce planning by service aggregates such as mental health or aged care rather than by professional discipline 8 . In Canada, the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada, which represents all medical disciplines except general practice, defines generalism as “a philosophy of care that is distinguished by a commitment to the breadth of practice within each discipline and collaboration with the larger health care team in order to respond to patient and community needs” 9 .…”

Widening participation in medicine? New insights from school students’ aspirations

“…Our findings suggest that the primary and secondary school years provide a critical juncture for targeting wider participation in medicine. If medical schools are to diversify the pool of applicants and recruit a more representative student body, the discursive tension between excellence and social accountability within medicine must be addressed . Indeed, regulation of who enters medical school constitutes an act of power .…”