Maximizing Women's Motivation in Domains Dominated by Men: Personally Known Versus Famous Role Models

Abstract

Two studies ( n = 1,522) examined the impact of role models in sport and science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) domains where gender discrimination has resulted in a lack of high-profile women. We examined the role of gender matching of personally known and famous exemplars on women's and men's motivation. Participants nominated a woman or man in sport (Study 1) or STEM (Study 2) who was either famous or known to them personally; they then indicated the extent to which they perceived this individual to be a motivating role model. Women and men were more motivated by personally known (vs. famous) role models. For famous exemplars, both women and men were most motivated by same-gender models (Studies 1 and 2). For personally known exemplars, men were similarly motivated by same- and other-gender models (Studies 1 and 2), but women were more motivated by same-gender models in sport (Study 1). Mediation analyses indicated that personally known (vs. famous) exemplars and, for women, same- (vs. other-) gender exemplars, were perceived as more attainable future selves and consequently were more motivating (Study 2). Given that there are fewer famous women in domains dominated by men, it is important to know if women can be inspired by personally known rather than famous individuals. These studies provide insight into the kinds of exemplars that are most motivating for women and may serve as a guide for educators and other practitioners seeking to provide the best role models for girls and women in domains dominated by men. Additional online materials for this article are available on PWQ's website at http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/suppl/10.1177/03616843231156165 .

Analysis of factors influencing women's participation in engineering education: An improved fuzzy DEMATEL approach

“…This finding appears to contradict many study findings [8]. However, as a recent study noted, women in male‐dominated fields are more motivated by personally known role models than by famous exemplars because they are seen as more attainable representations of the future self [19]. In China, famous figures often serve as role models for students, and this approach may be less effective at motivating WPEE, as girls cannot “see themselves” in future development.…”

Most influential women neurosurgeons on Twitter

“…Though mentorship from anyone, regardless of gender, is invaluable, research has shown that having same-gender role models for women interested in professions that are male dominated increases motivation, performance, and perceived attainability of reaching professional goals. 26 , 27 This type of mentorship is unique because it can better represent a future self and counteract negative gender stereotypes. 28 This ultimately empowers individuals with the belief that they too can be successful in their desired field.…”

A systematic review of the factors affecting girls' participation in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics subjects

“…• Motivate students for STEM achievement. [4,45,89,105,111,112,115,116,134] Behavior Role-model • Encouraging girls to choose and write about a favorite role model actively.…”