“…Because most valleys are steeper than the gradient required for stationary equilibrium river flow, most dynamic systems behave by maximizing energy expenditure. This explains why the extremal hypotheses of maximum energy expenditure, maximum friction factor, maximum flow resistance or maximum rate of energy dissipation have each been proposed as the fundamental principle governing alluvial channel flow (see, e.g., Jefferson, 1902;Schoklitsch, 1937;Inglis, 1947;Sutherland, 1980, 1983;Huang, 1983Huang, , 1988Abrahams et al, 1995;Lamberti, 1988;Phillips, 1991;Eaton et al, 2004). However, these extremal hypotheses are valid only if they deal specifically with the excess portion of available energy, or E − E min , when E > E min .…”