In this paper we introduce a novel noise model for quantum measurements motivated by an indirect measurement scheme with faulty preparation. Averaging over random dynamics governing the interaction between the quantum system and a probe, a natural, physical noise model emerges. We compare it to existing noise models (uniform and depolarizing) in the framework of incompatibility robustness. We observe that our model allows for larger compatibility regions for specific classes of measurements. Contents 1. Introduction 1 2. Quantum measurements 3 2.1. Compatibility 4 2.2. Noisy POVMs 5 3. Effective noise model via indirect measurements: the two outcomes case. 6 3.1. The two outcomes POVM induced by a perfect indirect measurement scheme 6 3.2. The noisy two outcomes POVM induced by an imperfect indirect measurement scheme 10 4. The case of arbitrary POVMs 12 4.1. General induced POVM 13 4.2. Physical noise model 14 5. Applications to compatibility 17 References 21