Measurement of serum zinc concentration in ruminants: a comparison of results from standard serum and specific trace element collection tubes

Abstract

Aims: To evaluate agreement between the concentration of Zn in serum from samples collected from cattle and sheep into standard collection tubes for serum and from samples collected into tubes developed for trace element measurement. Methods: Eighty-eight animals (78 cattle and 10 sheep) on eight farms had paired blood samples collected into standard serum and trace element vacutainers. The paired samples were submitted the same day to the laboratory to be tested for the concentration of Zn in serum using atomic absorption spectrophotometry. The agreement between the paired results was then assessed using limits of agreement analysis. On one farm an additional 10 pairs of samples was taken from the same animals; this second set of paired samples was refrigerated for 48 hours prior to laboratory submission to identify the impact of delaying submission on the apparent concentration of Zn in serum. Results: The limits of agreement analysis found no evidence of a systematic difference between Zn concentrations in serum collected into standard serum tubes and into trace element tubes as neither the intercept nor the slope on the mean-difference plot were significantly different from zero. The SD of the difference between results increased as the concentration of Zn increased, so at the lowest Zn concentration reported in this study (6.9 μmol/L) the limits of agreement were ±1.07 μmol/L, while at the highest (23.5 μmol/L) they were ±3.39 μmol/L. Refrigerating the sample (as whole blood) for 48 hours prior to submission increased the apparent concentration of Zn in serum in both standard serum tubes and trace element tubes by 1.3 μmol/L (95% CI = 0.75-1.85). Conclusions: There was no evidence that the concentration of Zn in serum from standard serum tubes were artificially elevated. In contrast, delaying sample submission by 48 hours did elevate Zn concentrations. Clinical relevance: While these data apply only to the batch of vacutainers used in this study, there is unlikely to be much between batch variation in the potential for contamination. Thus these results suggest that monitoring zinc status in ruminants, by measuring the concentration of Zn in serum from samples collected into standard serum tubes does not result in clinically relevant alterations in Zn concentration compared to using specific trace element tubes. However delaying submission to the laboratory may result in significantly elevated concentrations of Zn in serum so should be avoided. Abbreviations: FE: Facial eczema; SS: Standard blood collection tubes for serum analysis with no serum separation gel; TE: Blood collection tubes specifically designed for measurement of trace minerals in serum ARTICLE HISTORY