Measurements of Weight Bearing Asymmetry Using the Nintendo Wii Fit Balance Board Are Not Reliable for Older Adults and Individuals With Stroke

Abstract

Background Clinicians and researchers have used bathroom scales, balance performance monitors with feedback, postural scale analysis, and force platforms to evaluate weight bearing asymmetry (WBA). Now video game consoles offer a novel alternative for assessing this construct. By using specialized software, the Nintendo Wii Fit balance board can provide reliable measurements of WBA in healthy, young adults. However, reliability of measurements obtained using only the factory settings to assess WBA in older adults and individuals with stroke has not been established. Purpose To determine whether measurements of WBA obtained using the Nintendo Wii Fit balance board and default settings are reliable in older adults and individuals with stroke. Methods Weight bearing asymmetry was assessed using the Nintendo Wii Fit balance board in 2 groups of participants—individuals older than 65 years (n = 41) and individuals with stroke (n = 41). Participants were given a standardized set of instructions and were not provided auditory or visual feedback. Two trials were performed. Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC), standard error of measure (SEM), and minimal detectable change (MDC) scores were determined for each group. Results The ICC for the older adults sample was 0.59 (0.35–0.76) with SEM95= 6.2% and MDC95= 8.8%. The ICC for the sample including individuals with stroke was 0.60 (0.47–0.70) with SEM95= 9.6% and MDC95= 13.6%. Discussion Although measurements of WBA obtained using the Nintendo Wii Fit balance board, and its default factory settings, demonstrate moderate reliability in older adults and individuals with stroke, the relatively high associated SEM and MDC values substantially reduce the clinical utility of the Nintendo Wii Fit balance board as an assessment tool for WBA. Conclusions Weight bearing asymmetry cannot be measured reliably in older adults and individuals with stroke using the Nintendo Wii Fit balance board without the use of specialized software.

Effectiveness of virtual reality therapy in chronic unilateral vestibular hypofunction: A randomized controlled study

“…Nintendo Wii is a therapy method that allows self-study. [ 8 ] Burns et al[ 9 ] reported in a study with healthy adults that Nintendo Wii games were well tolerated by individuals aged 21 to 65 years.…”

Reliability and minimal detectable change of body-weight distribution and body sway between right and left brain-damaged patients at a chronic stage

“…That said, the absolute reliability assessed by standard error of measurement (SEM) is as important to be considered. Indeed, in the case of repetitive assessments, SEM is a parameter that indicates the amount of random error [8] (i.e., a lower value indicates good reliability [2]). In addition, the use of the SEM provides several advantages over relative reliability, as an estimate of reliability that includes the units of measurement can determine the minimal difference between the first and second evaluation to ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT -CLEAN COPY 3 be considered as a true change and not just due to a test-retest error [9].…”

Concurrent and discriminant validity of Nintendo Wii Fit <i>exergame</i> for the assessment of postural sway

“…In addition, his adult participants ranged from 18 to 57 years, which may have affected his results as the validity of Wii Fit could be age dependent. Liuzzo et al reported that Wii Fit was moderately reliable for the elderly above 65 years (ICC 0.59), and for adults and elderly with stroke from 54 to 80 years (ICC 0.60) 25) . However, the only Wii Fit parameter that they measured was percentage of left and right weightbearing which is more indicative of static alignment, rather than postural sway.…”