“…Panel 1: Papers by level of application # Level Papers 23 higher education public institutions (An et al, 2019;Y. Chen et al, 2021;Despotis et al, 2015;Ding et al, 2020;Tavares et al, 2021;C.-D. Tran & Villano, 2018, 2021Visbal-Cadavid et al, 2019;Wang et al, 2019;Yang et al, 2018); private institutions (Johnes, 2013;Lee & Johnes, 2021;Shamohammadi & Oh, 2019); private and public or not specified (Aviles- Chodakowska, 2015;Lee & Worthington, 2016;Madria et al, 2019;Meza et al, 2018); departments (Kashim et al, 2018;Koronakos et al, 2019); colleges (Esmaeilzadeh & Matin, 2019;Monfared & Safi, 2013); university hospital (Lobo et al, 2016) 3 primary and/or secondary Avilés Sacoto et al, 2015;Grosskopf et al, 2015;Wanke et al, China (An et al, 2019;Y. Chen et al, 2021;Ding et al, 2020;Wang et al, 2019;Yang et al, 2018); Philippines (Madria et al, 2019); Korea (Shamohammadi & Oh, 2019); Vietnam (C.-D. Tran & Villano, 2018, 2021; Iran (Esmaeilzadeh & Matin, 2019;Monfared & Safi, 2013) 5 Europe…”