Smartphones, tablets, and computers offer a wealth of digital information about the world and have transformed the ways we live. Our experiences of the world are now so much more mediated by digital devices than ever before. This is especially the case for living with (and under) the influences of our weather and climate. Here, we explore the idea that an ongoing digitalization of weather and climate, vis-à-vis technology, and the evolving discourse about them may be minimizing or obscuring the actual phenomenological experiencing of weather and climate. We first discuss trends in the digital portrayal of weather and climate and then contrast these with embodied experiences of the weather which, together with “old-school” physical observation techniques, we refer to as an analogue experiencing of the weather. In the third section, we discuss the value of integrating both digitalized and analogue experiences of the weather. Finally, we introduce some ways to become more attuned to the weather of one’s place while locating these experiences on the larger landscape of data and digitalized meteorology.