Measuring Migration: Profiling Residential Mobility across Two Decades

Abstract

The demography of a local population is a central aspect of applied social science research. Although birth and death rates influence a population, the key contributing factor influencing the demographics of a locality is almost always internal migration—the movement of persons between U.S. regions, states, and localities. Current definitions of internal migration used by the U.S. Census Bureau are limited because confidentiality restrictions require that detailed current and former place of residence geographic information be suppressed in publicly available files. In this paper we report the results of our work with confidential versions of the 1990 and 2000 decennial census microdata to develop an improved measurement of migration in order to develop a profile of internal migration in the United States. We perform our analysis for two contrasting time periods, 1985–1990 and 1995–2000. Our interest here is to assess the stability of the profile of migrants during a time period of economic contraction and expansion. Using confidential internal versions of the 1990 and 2000 Census long-form microdata, we estimate logistic models of the likelihood that individuals will migrate. The geographic detail in the internal Census data permits us to measure migration in ways that are not possible with public-domain Census data on persons. We develop migration definitions that distinguish between local residential mobility likely associated with life course transitions from migration out of the labor market area that may be driven more by employment and other socioeconomic considerations. Using logistic modeling, we find that the same individual attributes predict migration reasonably well during both periods. We also compute some illustrative probabilities of migration that show temporal stability in migration predictors could be lessened by certain changes in population composition.

Evaluating the Internal Labor Migration Effects of Compulsory Peacetime Conscription

“…Thus, expression (5) in Lewbel (2007) suggests that misclassification may attenuate the estimated effects of conscription by just about 5%. Blanchard, and Irwin 2009). And third, the exhaustive partition of metropolitan France into 348 commuting zones that remained unaltered until 2010 removes concerns about identifying migrations consistently in different editions of Generation.…”

Community Banks and Loans for Nonmetropolitan Businesses: A Multilevel Analysis from the 2007 Survey of Business Owners

“…Business owners are grouped at the second level by a spatial measure of the local economy: commuting zones (CZs). Based on cluster models of intercounty journey‐to‐work patterns, these CZs have been widely used since the 1980s to better encompass the flow of economic activity across politically or arbitrarily drawn county lines (Killian and Tolbert ; Tolbert, Blanchard, and Irwin ) . The underlying commuting data are county‐to‐county journey‐to‐work tabulations from decennial censuses (census 2000 in this case).…”

Spatial dispersion of U.S. national origin groups: Characteristics of dispersed immigrants and settlement places

“…The 741 spatial units cover the entire USA, including metropolitan and nonmetropolitan areas, and correspond to local labour markets. They were based on a set of spatial units that Tolbert, Blanchard, and Irwin (, ) developed by using cluster analysis to identify contiguous counties that had close socio‐economic linkages and commuting patterns in 1990. To obtain a set of geographic areas that had the same boundaries in 1990, 2000, and 2007–2011, a small number of county adjustments were made.…”