Measuring sense of place in social-ecological systems: a review of literature and future research needs

Duggan, Joe; Cvitanovic, Christopher; Putten, Ingrid van

doi:10.1080/26395916.2022.2162968

Cited by 14 publications

(3 citation statements)

References 114 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…In the Middle East, the focus of the study was on Turkey, and Iran, while Arabian countries are the least represented in this region. This distribution of studies, shown in Figure 2, aligns with findings from other research that indicates a focus of research in this field on privileged populations (the Global North) [14,15,16].…”

Section: The Significance Of Geographical Context In the Study Of The...supporting

confidence: 86%

“…Mixed methods were most frequently used to include both the quantitative and qualitative aspects of these concepts. They were most frequently used to collect data, with surveys and interviews being the most popular methods [14]. Another emerging trend in this domain is the adoption of frequently used models from the literature, such as: PA scale by Williams and Vaske [84] which was used in [25,66] Community-Dwelling Older Adults (PACOA) scale [73], the Fuzzy Analytic Network Process (FANP) model [69], the Place Attachment Scale by Lewicka [6], the Urban Identity Scale of Lalli [7], and the Abbreviated PA Scale (APAS) [31].…”

Section: Operationalization Of Place Attachment and Sense Of Place In...mentioning

confidence: 99%

See 1 more Smart Citation

Developing a conceptual framework for studying people-place relationship

Yousef,

Valánszki

2023

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The development of research on people-place relationships is a complex and multi-disciplinary field, and over time has evolved in different ways across different disciplines. Despite this development, research on the impact of geographical and cultural context on the conceptualization and management of people-place relationships is still lacking. The article seeks to contribute to the development of a conceptual framework for place-based constructs of attachment by investigating the impact of geographical context on the conceptualization and operationalization of people-place relationships. The study reviews previous research on spatial studies and systematically analyses the geographical context of those studies to comprehend how it affects the conceptualization and operationalization of place-based constructs such as sense of place (SOP) and place attachment (PA). The analysis includes a critical assessment and case study analysis of previous studies, with a comparative analysis of the geographical contextof the study, the conceptualizing framework, the methods, and tools used, and the application of the results. Our findings show insignificant influences of the special characteristics of geographical context on the conceptualization and operationalization of these concepts, with only a few attempts to assess the validity and reliability of measurement models across different contexts. The study also highlights the need for more research on the cultural-geographical context of people-place relationships, as it provides a better understanding of how geographical and cultural factors can provide a more complete picture of how people form attachments to places and how these attachments influence their behaviour and well-being.

show abstract

Section: The Significance Of Geographical Context In the Study Of The...supporting

confidence: 86%

Section: Operationalization Of Place Attachment and Sense Of Place In...mentioning

confidence: 99%

Developing a conceptual framework for studying people-place relationship

Yousef,

Valánszki

2023

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…The human team consisted of ve humans (PT, JD, DK, RS, RAJ) with expertise in undertaking various forms of evidence synthesis (e.g. (Duggan et al, 2023;Karcher et al, 2021)). The AI team consisted of four humans (SS, MA, FB, RT) with modelling expertise, who employed a Generative Pre-trained Transformer model (GPT), a proprietary AI large language model developed by OpenAI (Brown et al, 2020), to produce outputs.…”

mentioning

confidence: 99%

Human-AI Collaboration to Identify Literature for Evidence Synthesis

Spillias

Tuohy

Andreotta

et al. 2023

Preprint

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Systematic approaches to evidence synthesis can improve the rigour, transparency, and replicability of a traditional literature review. However, these systematic approaches are time and resource intensive. We evaluate the ability of OpenAI’s ChatGPT to undertake two initial stages of evidence syntheses (searching peer-reviewed literature and screening for relevance) and develop a novel collaborative framework to leverage the best of both human and AI intelligence. Using a scoping review of community-based fisheries management as a case study, we find that with substantial prompting, the AI can provide critical insight into the construction and content of a search string. Thereafter, we evaluate five strategies for synthesising AI output to screen articles based on predefined inclusion criteria. We find low omission rates (< 1%) of relevant literature by the AI are achievable, which is comparable to that of human screeners. These findings show that generalised AI tools can assist reviewers with evidence synthesis to accelerate the implementation and improve the reliability of a review.

show abstract

Taking knowledge exchange to practice: A scoping review of practical case studies to identify enablers of success in environmental management

Kapoor,

Cvitanovic,

Klenk

et al. 2024

Env Pol Gov

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

A gap exists in the literature on how to implement theories of knowledge exchange (KE) into practice within an environmental management context. To support the improved practice of KE, we conducted a scoping literature review evaluating 56 empirical case studies globally to identify enabling conditions for implementing effective KE. Identified enabling conditions were organized into a core capacities framework, which highlighted essential elements of effective KE from organizational, individual, financial, material, practical, political, and social capacity dimensions. Results show that major enablers to effective KE relate to practitioners' individual and organizational capacity including the ability of practitioners (often boundary spanners) to establish trust with relevant actors through their interpersonal relationships and possessing sufficient background knowledge and skills to facilitate collaborations across disciplines and sectors. We also identified main challenges to engaging in KE (e.g., insufficient long‐ term funding for projects, lack of interpersonal skills for KE practitioners to build relationships and network, and inadequate background knowledge for practitioners to exchange knowledge in an accessible manner), and the outcomes and impacts that can emerge from effective KE work. We find that practitioners often perform quantitative evaluations that provide instantaneous and measurable impacts for the effectiveness of KE, but do not capture the impact of interpersonal relationships and trust that are best achieved through qualitative approaches. Lastly, the synthesis of enablers, challenges, outcomes, and impacts presented in this paper can be a resource for practitioners to identify what enablers may be missing from their KE strategies and in what capacity the KE work can be strengthened.

show abstract

Measuring sense of place in social-ecological systems: a review of literature and future research needs

Cited by 14 publications

References 114 publications

Developing a conceptual framework for studying people-place relationship

Developing a conceptual framework for studying people-place relationship

Human-AI Collaboration to Identify Literature for Evidence Synthesis

Taking knowledge exchange to practice: A scoping review of practical case studies to identify enablers of success in environmental management

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About