This study examined differing attributes that motivate corporate sustainability practices and performance (CSP&P) in the global economy. Utilizing publicly disclosed information from the Carbon Disclosure Project (CDP), data were gathered for publicly listed companies operating in high carbon-intensive and less carbon-intensive sectors on a global scale, and a panel ordered probit regression model analysis was conducted to arrive at the findings. The rigorous reliability and validity of the scales were ensured. Firm-level attributes, industry-specific factors, stakeholder pressure, and country-level attributes were the variables examined for each context. The findings reveal that the firm-level attributes showed that board size, board independence, sustainability committee, and firm size were linked to positive motivation, while firm age was found to negatively influence the response level. The study discovered that the industry-specific factors variable has a negative significant influence because industry leaders (firms in high carbon-intensive sectors) exhibit poor sustainability performance, suggesting a negative attitude towards environmental issues. The study discovered a positive and highly significant influence of stakeholder pressure, while country-level attributes partially played a significant role. Overall, the findings show that a disparity exists in the level of response between the different global economies. The justification for the findings is based on the theory of interested parties, political theory, and legitimacy concerns that shape the strategic choices made by companies.