Measuring the socialization of graduate and diplomate nurses using the Corwin Role Orientation Scale

Abstract

Measuring the socialization of graduate and diplomate nurses using the Corwin Role Orientation Scale The nature of United Kingdom (UK) nursing education has changed signi®cantly as the responsibility has been transferred from hospitals to the University sector. More information is needed on the outcome of the Project 2000 diploma and degree courses given the rapidly changing health care context. This paper focuses on the role socialization of graduate and diploma nurses. As part of a larger study, this research investigated the role orientations of 52 nursing graduates and 28 diplomates from two different universities at three time points; on graduation and at 6 and 12 months postgraduation. The Corwin Role Orientation Scale was selected and modi®ed for the study. It comprised of three separate scales measuring professional, bureaucratic and service orientation. The data from the two groups of nurses were examined to identify nurses' ideal role orientations and role discrepancies over the transitionary period from graduate to quali®ed nurse. Although the results showed observed differences between the groups over time, none of these differences were statistically signi®cant. The ®ndings raise a number of questions about the value of the instrument as a measure in the contemporary nursing context. Furthermore, each of the Corwin subscales had a low internal reliability. A possible explanation may be that the instrument, which was developed in the United States of America (USA) in the 1960s, and modi®ed, for this study, has little relevance for contemporary UK nursing. The study ®ndings are also limited by the small size of the sample. In spite of these limitations, the study suggests there are few differences between the role orientations and socialization experiences of UK nursing graduates and diplomates. Indeed, both programmes commonly take place in university settings and students receive the same amount of clinical experience. Further instrument development and exploratory research is recommended to identify the role socialization and orientations of UK nurses through larger national studies.

Preparing nurses for practice: A phenomenological study of the new graduate in Australia

“…Being considered 'an insider' is important in relation to the success of organisational socialisation (Hagerty & Patusky 1995, Tradewell 1996. Furthermore, the participants' experiences support findings in the literature that it is not until the graduate is a member of the workplace that they are able to conceptualise the components associated with fitting in (Brighid 1996, Taylor et al 2001. It seems that, as students, the participants had no idea of 'nursing culture' despite the hundreds of clinical practice hours they had spent in health care settings.…”

Sacrificing the personal to the professional: community mental health nurses

“…Firstly, there is a risk of exaggerating the unity and stasis of a nursing identity. In the UK educational initiatives in nursing, such as the development of large scale degree‐level education, have changed the nature of the nursing role and affected nurses' sense of identity (Taylor et al . 2001).…”

Professional development utilizing an oncology summer nursing internship

“…Taylor et al (2001) studied socialization of graduate nurses utilizing Corwin's Role Orientation Scale, comprised of three scales measuring professional, bureaucratic, and service orientation. The researchers found a deficit in role socialization in the newly graduated nurse.…”