Measuring the Transaction Costs of Historical Shifts to Informal Drought Management Institutions in Italy

Abstract

<jats:p>Coase shows how costly resources are (re)allocated via costly institutions, and that transaction costs must therefore be positive. However, Coase did not elaborate on transitions between institutions which incur positive transaction costs that are characterized by numerous institutional complementarities; that is, feedback loops that inform the need for, and pathways toward, institutional change. Economic investigations of complementary modes of (re)allocation are rarely undertaken, let alone studies of transitions between modes. However, modes of (re)allocation that achieve similar results at less cost are generally viewed as having production-raising value. This paper measures the costs of transitioning drought management institutions in Italy toward informal, participatory, and consensus-based approaches during several recent drought events. The chosen model is Drought Steering Committees, which offer a substitute for current formal (less flexible) planning approaches, and where lower transaction costs that are associated with the transition are inferred. Our results highlight the relevance of empirical assessments of ‘costly’ transitions based on a historical study of transaction costs, as well as supporting previous works that highlight the value of contextual analysis in economic studies, in order to identify the benefits of institutional investment.</jats:p>

Strategies to Control Industrial Emissions: An Analytical Network Process Approach in East Java, Indonesia

“…This may be because CAC and market-based policies are more suitable for industrial regions or developed countries, such as China and the USA [27,35,48]. In Italy, CAC is preferable to market-based approaches because the latter require state intervention in resource and sanction management [69]. Previous studies tended to support market-based policies or CAC more than the institutional approach because they often as-sociated institutional processes (political, administrative, and legal) with higher transaction costs [69].…”

“…In Italy, CAC is preferable to market-based approaches because the latter require state intervention in resource and sanction management [69]. Previous studies tended to support market-based policies or CAC more than the institutional approach because they often as-sociated institutional processes (political, administrative, and legal) with higher transaction costs [69]. In China, Tang et al [49] noted that the impact of instruments, such as the TDP, highly depends on market perfection, pointing out that as institutional transaction costs increase, innovation and its effects decrease.…”

Drought in the Po Valley: Identification, Impacts and Strategies to Manage the Events

“…Ref. [78] assessed the costs of transitioning drought management institutions in Italy toward informal, participatory and consensus-based approaches during several recent drought events. The work analyzed the allocation of water abstraction licences in the Po basin and concluded that there is an over-allocation of such licences.…”

Drought and society: Scientific progress, blind spots, and future prospects

“…Some studies use their analyses to define a set of tools aimed at building more resilient governance systems and institutions or developing innovative adaptation strategies for future drought events (Du et al, 2018 ; Hurlbert & Gupta, 2019 ; King‐Okumu et al, 2018 ; Lordkipanidze et al, 2015 ; Nguyen et al, 2021 ; Sousa Júnior et al, 2016 ; Sullivan et al, 2019 ; Vignola et al, 2018 ). Other studies devote their effort to design novel analytical frameworks that support policy making alongside natural resources or risk managements practices (Bettini et al, 2013 ; Habiba et al, 2011 ; Harou et al, 2010 ; Hund et al, 2018 ; Loch et al, 2020 ; Yates et al, 2013 ).…”