Measuring Underground (Unobserved, Non-Observed, Unrecorded) Economies in Transition Countries: Can We Trust GDP?

Abstract

This paper compiles alternative estimates of underground economies in twenty five transition countries during the transition decade and finds a disturbing lack of convergence between them, calling into question the reliability of GDP figures (which in varying degrees now include non-transparent imputations for the "nonobserved economy") as well as the macro model estimates of the unrecorded economy. A corollary of this finding is that substantive results from many studies examining the consequences of the radical transition from planned to market economies must be viewed with considerable skepticism. Underground (unobserved, non-observed, unrecorded) economic activities play a major role in transition economies. Evaluations of the success and failure of the transition experience should be based on estimates of total economic activity (TEA) namely, recorded plus unrecorded economic activity. We examine the conceptual and empirical relationships between new National Income and Product Accounts (NIPA) methods for obtaining "exhaustive" measures of total economic activity and the two most popular macro-model approaches (electric consumption and currency ratio models) for estimating the size and growth of the unrecorded sector. Our updated empirical results detailing the size and trajectory of unrecorded activities obtained from different estimation methods reveal a disturbing lack of convergence. Until these important differences are resolved, investigations of the relationship between economic reforms and economic outcomes during the transition decade must be viewed with considerable caution. Given the shortcomings of conventional macro model estimates of the underground economy and the lack of transparency and consistency of NOE estimates, it is high time that the profession acknowledges how little we really know about underground economies and their causes and consequences.

Labor Tax Avoidance and Its Determinants: The Case of Mafia Firms in Italy

“…Finally, applying the same MIMIC method to the Spanish case, Alañón and Gómez-Antonio (2005) find a considerable shadow economy, measuring between 8 and 18.8% of GDP in the period , and demonstrate that the shadow economy is significantly influenced by the tax burden, the degree of regulation and unit labor costs. Some indirect methods have been criticized because of the questionable basic assumptions and the unreliable macroeconomic estimates on which they rely (Schneider and Enste, 2000;Ahumada et al, 2007;Feige and Urban, 2008).…”

Modeling the Spatiotemporal Dynamics of Gross Domestic Product in China Using Extended Temporal Coverage Nighttime Light Data

“…However, GDP is often inadequately measured in developing countries due to the poor governmental statistical infrastructure [2,3]. Worse, economic statistical data Compared with DMSP-OLS, therefore, NPP-VIIRS provides a more powerful approach to research the nighttime light.…”

America’s unreported economy: measuring the size, growth and determinants of income tax evasion in the U.S.

“…27 It should be noted that the widely cited and severely critiqued (Breusch, 2005, a, b, c;2006) MIMIC model estimates are all presumably based on some highly simplified, albeit undocumented, currency demand approach. 28 Similar concerns are expressed in Feige and Urban (2008) in their investigation of estimates of the "unrecorded" economy in transition countries.…”

“…See Feige (1989) and Feige and Urban (2008). d) The ratio of currency to checkable deposits in the observed sector is constant over time.…”