Amyloid-b (Ab) and hyperphosphorylated tau (p-tau) aggregates form the two discrete pathologies of Alzheimer disease (AD), and oligomeric assemblies of each protein are localized to synapses. To determine the sequence by which pathology appears in synapses, Ab and p-tau were quantified across AD disease stages in parietal cortex. Nondemented cases with high levels of AD-related pathology were included to determine factors that confer protection from clinical symptoms. Flow cytometric analysis of synaptosome preparations was used to quantify Ab and p-tau in large populations of individual synaptic terminals. Soluble Ab oligomers were assayed by a single antibody sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Total in situ Ab was elevated in patients with early-and late-stage AD dementia, but not in high pathology nondemented controls compared with age-matched normal controls. However, soluble Ab oligomers were highest in early AD synapses, and this assay distinguished early AD cases from high pathology controls. Overall, synapse-associated p-tau did not increase until late-stage disease in human and transgenic rat cortex, and p-tau was elevated in individual Ab-positive synaptosomes in early AD. These results suggest that soluble oligomers in surviving neocortical synaptic terminals are associated with dementia onset and suggest an amyloid cascade hypothesis in which oligomeric Ab drives phosphorylated tau accumulation and synaptic spread. These results indicate that antiamyloid therapies will be less effective once p-tau pathology is developed. (Am J Pathol 2016, 186: 185e198; http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ajpath.2015 A large body of evidence indicates that soluble oligomers of amyloid-b (Ab) are the primary toxic peptides that initiate downstream tau pathology in the amyloid cascade hypothesis of Alzheimer disease (AD). 1,2 However, the time course and severity of AD dementia have been generally found to correlate with neurofibrillary tangle development rather than plaque appearance, 3e8 although a few studies have linked plaques with early cognitive decline. 9e12 Soluble oligomeric