A new series of tetranuclear iron clusters displaying an interstitial μ4-F ligand was prepared for comparison to μ4-O analogs. With a single NO coordinated as a reporter of small molecule activation, the μ4-F clusters were characterized in five redox states, from FeII3{FeNO}8 to FeIII3{FeNO}7, with N–O stretching frequencies ranging from 1680 cm−1 to 1855 cm−1, respectively. Despite accessing more reduced states with an F− bridge, a two electron reduction of the distal Fe centers is necessary for the μ4-F clusters to activate NO to the same degree as the μ4-O system; consequently, NO reactivity is observed at more positive potentials with μ4-O than μ4-F. Moreover, the μ4-O ligand better translates redox changes of remote metal centers to diatomic ligand activation. The implication for biological active sites is that the higher charge bridging ligand is more effective in tuning cluster properties, including the involvement of remote metal centers, for small molecule activation