Mechanistic understanding of electro- and
photocatalytic CO<sub>2</sub> reduction is crucial to develop strategies to overcome
catalytic bottlenecks. In this regard, herein
it is presented a new CO<sub>2</sub>-to-CO reduction cobalt aminopyridine catalyst,
a detailed experimental and theoretical mechanistic study toward the
identification of bottlenecks and potential strategies to alleviate them. The combination
of electrochemical and <i>in-situ</i>
spectroelectrochemical (FTIR/UV-Vis SEC) studies together with spectroscopic
techniques (NMR, EXAFS) lead us to identify elusive key electrocatalytic
intermediates derived from complex [Co(py<sup>Me</sup>tacn)(OTf)<sub>2</sub>] (<b>1</b>)
(py<sup>Me</sup>tacn = 1-[2-pyridylmethyl]-4,7-dimethyl-1,4,7-triazacyclononane)
such as a highly reactive cobalt (I) (<b>1<sup>(I)</sup></b>) and cobalt (I)
carbonyl (<b>1<sup>(I)</sup>-CO</b>) species. <b>1<sup>(I)</sup></b> was
obtained by electrochemical reduction of <b>1<sup>(II)</sup></b>, and
characterized by NMR, EXAFS and FTIR/UV-Vis SEC. The combination of spectroelectrochemical
studies under CO<sub>2</sub>, <sup>13</sup>CO<sub>2</sub> and CO with DFT disclosed
that <b>1<sup>(I)</sup></b> directly reacts with CO<sub>2</sub> to form the
pivotal <b>1<sup>(I)</sup>-CO</b> intermediate at the <b>1<sup>(II/I) </sup></b>redox
potential. At this redox potential the theoretical energy barrier for the C-O
bond cleavage was found to be as low as 12.2 kcal·mol<sup>-1</sup>. However, the
catalytic process does not proceed at the <b>1<sup>(II/I) </sup></b>redox
potential, due to the formation of <b>1<sup>(I)</sup>-CO, </b>which is a thermodynamic
sink and the CO release restricts the electrocatalysis. In agreement with the
experimental observed CO<sub>2</sub>-to-CO electrocatalysis at the <b>1<sup>(I/0)
</sup></b>redox potential, computational studies suggested that the productive
electrocatalytic cycle involves striking metal carbonyl intermediates such as [L<sup>N4</sup>Co<sup>0</sup>CO]
(L<sup>N4</sup> = py<sup>Me</sup>tacn), [L<sup>N4</sup>Co<sup>II</sup>(CO<sub>2</sub>)CO]
and [L<sup>N4</sup>Co<sup>I</sup>CO)<sub>2</sub>]. In contrast, under photochemical
conditions, the catalytic process smoothly proceeds at the <b>1<sup>(II/I) </sup></b>redox
potential. Under the latter conditions,
it is proposed that the electron transfer rate is under diffusion control and then
the CO release from <b>1<sup>(II)</sup>-CO</b> is kinetically favored,
facilitating the catalysis. Finally, we have found that visible light
irradiation has a positive impact under electrocatalytic conditions.
We envision that light irradiation can serve
as an effective strategy to improve the CO<sub>2</sub> reduction of molecular
catalysts, <i>via</i> alleviating bottlenecks, such as the CO poisoning.