Medical student residency preferences and motivational factors: a longitudinal, single-institution perspective

Abstract

Background A high proportion of medical school graduates pursue specialties different from those declared at matriculation. While these choices influence the career paths, satisfaction, and potential regret students will experience, they also impact the supply and demand ratio of the shorthanded physician workforce across many specialties. In this study, we investigate how the choice of medical specialty and the factors motivating those choices change between the beginning and end of medical school training. Methods A questionnaire was administered annually from 2017 to 2020 to a cohort of medical students at the University of Connecticut to determine longitudinal preferences regarding residency choice, motivational factors influencing residency choice, future career path, and demographic information. Results The questionnaire respondent totals were as follows: n = 76 (Year 1), n = 54 (Year 2), n = 31 (Year 3), and n = 65 (Year 4). Amongst newly matriculated students, 25.0% were interested in primary care, which increased ~ 1.4-fold to 35.4% in the final year of medical school. In contrast, 38.2% of matriculated students expressed interest in surgical specialties, which decreased ~ 2.5-fold to 15.4% in the final year. Specialty choices in the final year that exhibited the largest absolute change from matriculation were orthopedic surgery (− 9.9%), family medicine (+ 8.1%), radiology (+ 7.9%), general surgery (− 7.2%), and anesthesiology (+ 6.2%). Newly matriculated students interested in primary care demonstrated no differences in their ranking of motivational factors compared to students interested in surgery, but many of these factors significantly deviated between the two career paths in the final year. Specifically, students interested in surgical specialties were more motivated by the rewards of salary and prestige compared to primary care students, who more highly ranked match confidence and family/location factors. Conclusions We identified how residency choices change from the beginning to the end of medical school, how certain motivational factors change with time, how these results diverge between primary care and surgery specialty choice, and propose a new theory based on risk-reward balance regarding residency choice. Our study promotes awareness of student preferences and may help guide school curricula in developing more student-tailored training approaches. This could foster positive long-term changes regarding career satisfaction and the physician workforce.

What Matters Most: Determinants Associated with the Selection of Medical Residencies in Qatar

“…This is consistent with evidence from elsewhere that, at least for males, “students pursuing surgery…were more motivated by economics”. 36 Interestingly, this did not appear to be the case for our female respondents. The reason for this discrepancy is not clear and warrants further investigation.…”

Analysis of Perception of Gender Bias among Teaching Hospital Residents by Gender and Specialty: Insight from Medical Education in South Korea

“…We rst grouped residents by gender and specialty. In terms of specialty, clinical medicine specialties can be broadly categorized into medical, surgical, and clinical support [12][13][14][15]. In a second step, we performed exploratory factor analysis to explore the underlying structure of the PGBS and to improve the interpretability of the factors.…”

The CRAFT program: Clinical mentorship during first year of medical school can impact future career trajectory for choosing residency programs

“…Outside of the mandatory clinical curriculum, supplementation with longitudinal as well as auxiliary clinical experiences can spark student interest, as well as in uence the eld they choose to pursue for their future residency program [5]. This program offered an opportunity for faculty, staff, and students to connect with each other and offer medical services in diverse communities.…”