Medical student views of and responses to expectations of professionalism

Abstract

Context To earn society's trust, medical students must develop professional values and behaviours via a transformative process, from lay person to doctor. Yet students are expected to epitomise the values and behaviours of a doctor from the outset of medical school, leading them to feel ‘judged all the time’ (in terms of their professionalism). Our aim, therefore, is to extend knowledge exploring the expectations communicated to and perceived by medical students and to provide a conceptually framed understanding of students’ associated emotional tensions. Methods We used a qualitative exploratory case study methodology within a constructivist paradigm to explore the messages communicated about professionalism and students’ perceived expectations of professionalism in one medical school. Data were collected in the form of: (i) regulatory and medical school documents, and (ii) focus groups with 23 participants in their first 2 years at medical school. We used thematic analysis for data interpretation and two theoretical lenses, Amalberti et al.'s framework of system migration for health care and Sinclair's adaptation of Goffman's dramaturgical theory, to critically analyse the results. Results We found messages and perceived expectations of knowledge and competence, and the need to ensure trust. We also identified that the expectations of patients, doctors, society, family and friends are just as, if not more, influential than policy and regulatory expectations for early years’ medical students. Moreover, we found tensions, with students feeling that the expectations of them from others were unrealistic for their level of training. With this came a sense of pressure to meet expectations that participants responded to by acting as if already competent. Conclusions Our findings suggest that external forces (expectations) drive early years’ students to act as if competent. Although this is part of student identity formation it could also have implications for patient safety and therefore necessitates recognition and support from educators.

You are exactly my type! The traits of a good doctor: a factor analysis study on public's perspectives

“…The definition of a good doctor will depend on who is being asked [ 17 ]. There has been increasing emphasis on the attributes that patients [ 2 , 18 ], physicians [ 19 , 20 ], and medical students [ 8 , 21 , 22 ] value in a good doctor. These may differ from what the broader public considers important.…”

A Multimethod Examination of Medical Students’ Experiences With Bereavement and Complicated Grief

“…Professionalism describes the expectations placed on medical students to embody specific behaviors and values as a practicing physician (e.g., appearing to be more knowledgeable than their competency level, portrayal of confidence, dress code, ethical conduct, use of social media), some of which have been viewed by medical students as unrealistic. Additionally, it has been found to create emotional tension and resentment in medical students who have expressed losing their sense of individuality (Stubbing et al, 2019). Students were asked about their academic performance because loss is associated with academic difficulties in college students (Cupit et al, 2016).…”

A multi-year study on the changing perceptions of medical freshmen cohorts on societal expectations of physicians

“…The effect of such external forces to demonstrate competence, has a great impact on identity formation, which is a crucial part of medical education. (1).…”

“…The positive catalytic effect of such external forces such as patients, teachers, society, family and friends have been alluded to in several studies. (1). ( 2) (3) Leading medical education organizations like AAMC, AFIM, GMC and ACGME, have stepped up the criteria for professional behavior of physicians and have assessed the adequacy of professionalism education in medical schools.…”