Meeting the Discipline-Culture Framework of Physics Knowledge: A Teaching Experience in Italian Secondary School

Abstract

The paper deals with physics teaching/learning in high school. An investigation in three upper secondary school classes in Italy explored the reactions of students to a structuring lecture on optics within the discipline-culture (DC) framework that organises physics knowledge around four interrelated fundamental theories of light. The lecture presented optics as an unfolding conceptual discourse of physicists regarding the nature of light. Along with the knowledge constructed in a school course of a scientific lyceum, the students provided epistemological comments, displaying their perception of physics knowledge presented in the classroom. Students’ views and knowledge were investigated by questionnaires prior to and after the lecture and in special discussions held in each class. They revealed a variety of attitudes and views which allowed inferences about the potential of the DC framework in an educational context. The findings and interpretation indicate the positive and stimulating impact of the lecture and the way in which DC-based approach to knowledge organization makes physics at school cultural and attractive

Actual versus implied physics students: How students from traditional physics classrooms related to an innovative approach to quantum physics

“…A similar finding was reported by Levrini et al. () for Italian upper secondary students after a teaching intervention on optics and the nature of light where HPS aspects had a central role. Despite this interest and motivation, however, students in our investigation did not necessarily see HPS aspects as learning goals in their own right.…”

Draw Your Physics Homework? Art as a Path to Understanding in Physics Teaching

“…The course begins with the contemporary view of spacetime, motion, and gravity, rather than starting with the Newtonian mechanistic view. Levrini (1999) suggests that introducing the contemporary ideas about space and time into physics education early on can provide a powerful means of drawing learners into the study of physics because it interrogates “pre-scientific” concepts of space and time that have historically been at the center of cultural debates, and thus of general human interest. More importantly, space and time are historically of concern to other disciplines such as art, literature, and philosophy and thus can be a powerful bridge to other subjects, allowing for a comparison of the physics ways of looking at space with other points of view (Levrini, 1999).…”

What Is Light?

“…We have shown elsewhere that the teaching approach in ReleQuant with small-group discussions can be productive in the sense that they deepen students' understanding and make them ask new questions (Bungum et al, 2018). Along similar lines, Levrini et al (2014) observed that Italian upper secondary physics students refined their epistemological positions after a teaching intervention on optics and the nature of light where historical and philosophical aspects had a central role. The findings resonate with Krijtenburg-Lewerissa et al (2017) recommendations for quantum physics teaching strategies, which include emphasis on interpretations along with active learning methods.…”