Melting the Cold War Permafrost: Restructuring Military Industry in Scotland

Abstract

Military industry stands at the confluence of local, national and global processes. This paper examines the restructuring of this peculiar industry in one region, Scotland, from a perspective that takes the geography of production to be a joint, though contradictory, creation. Following the work of Lovering for the UK as a whole, the case of Scotland—often imagined as “militantly proletarian”—allows a specific study of the accumulation strategies of state and capital and the role of organized labor in mediating the spatial fix. Until the early 1990s accumulation was premised on additive “capital widening” strategies. Since then, both “capital narrowing” rationalization strategies and “capital deepening” intensification strategies have been pursued. Through restructuring, the UK military industry attempts to utilize the abstract spaces of the social economy to expediently and opportunistically reconstitute the concrete spaces of production and renegotiate its dependency on the refractory material of proximate living labor. Yet spatial shifts have not uniformly benefited the southern core of the UK military industry. One reason for thecontinuing salience of military industry in Scotland has been the role of a pan‐class alliance, “the Scottish lobby,” in campaigning against closures and for the allocation of defense contracts. Trade unions have attempted to mediate the contradictions of restructuring by supporting external strategies to retain firm survival in their present localities, even as internally workforce numbers are cut in half and management regimes become more abrasive.

Geopolitics and ‘the vision thing’: regarding Britain and America's first nuclear missile

“…So if the human gaze situates the observer in the world, the military gaze establishes the political space of the state in a world of competing sovereignty. As part of this contest, the Hebrides were recruited as a territorial fringe set aside for the ‘infinite preparation’ of a ‘pure war’, in which states of war and peace, being mutually enfolded, were endlessly deferred: ‘neither war nor peace but permanent logistic struggle in which warfare preparations reorganize social and economic relations in order to secure peace’ (Luke and Ó Tuathail 2000, 367; Luke 1989; see also Law 1999).…”

From Military Geography to militarism's geographies: disciplinary engagements with the geographies of militarism and military activities

“…A small selection ofexamples of work in this area would include: Melman (I19 7 0; 1988); Markusen et at (I199 1); Smith (1993); Economic Geography special issue (1993); Law et a. (1993); Inbar and Zilberfarb (1998); Gray and Markusen (1999); Law (1999); Lumpe (2000); Guay (2001);and Bitzinger (2003). Analysis has also focused on the confluence of defence industrial and national security agendas (Lovering, 1990; 2 0 0 0; Kaldor and Schm6der, 1997;Calhoun, 2002;der Derian, 2001) and the privatization of military power (Singer, 2004).…”

The last outpost of Empire: Rockall and the Cold War

“…When the geographies of international security were once again being reconfigured at the beginning of the Cold War, the west of Scotland emerged as a major place d'armes within the northern hemisphere. 39 The Outer Hebrides in particular had a commanding position overlooking the North Atlantic. They were on the shortest routes by air and sea between Europe and North America and had significant areas of sparsely populated land.…”