Little is known about infectious complications of lumbar puncture (LP) in children. We reviewed records of children with bacterial meningitis, intraspinal abscess, and vertebral osteomyelitis over a 3-year period to identify infections following LP. Four children with bacterial meningitis and 1 child with vertebral osteomyelitis were identified and their clinical presentations were described. These cases were scored by infectious disease experts, using a Likert scale, for the possibility of iatrogenic causation; these scores were variable, reflecting uncertainty. The bacterial meningitis cases had repeat LPs, and the latter cerebrospinal fluid analyses were diagnostic of bacterial meningitis; the interval between the initial “index” LP (I-LP) and symptom onset was 8 to 10 hours in most cases. Pediatricians should be aware of this possibility, and have a low threshold to repeat LP if there is a clinical change after the I-LP that could be consistent with meningitis.